413 | Why was the Abd Al Malik-Al Hajjaj Paradigm Lost?

Al Fadi and Dr Jay Smith continue discussing Shoemaker's book; Creating the Quran.   Today they are wondering what happened to the Al Hajjaj- Abd Al Malik paradigm. They are not convinced with Shoemaker's answer, but they think it is a political reason since Abd Al Malik is an Umayyad , and the Abbasid came after them.  They continue to talk about another scholar Robert Hoyland who said that none of the previous religions in the seventh century has heard of a book called the Quran.  Then they conclude that the strongest arguments for a later Quran is the manuscripts evidence which they are going to discuss in details in later episodes.

 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.