#49 – The Retreat to Commitment by W.W. Bartley, Appendix 4 – Part 2

This episode of the Popperian Podcast is part of a series on William Bartley and his book The Retreat to Commitment.

** John Post's description of the alleged paradox within pancritical rationalism, as presented by William Bartley on page 224 of The Retreat to Commitment:

Since (B) is implied by (A), any criticism of (B) will constitute a criticism of (A), and thus show that (A) is open to criticism. Assuming that a criticism of (B) argues that (B) is false, we may argue: if (B) is false, then (A) is false; but an argument showing (A) to be false (and thus criticizing it) shows (B) to be true. Thus, if (B) is false, then (B) is true. Any attempt to criticize (B) demonstrates (B); thus (B) is uncriticizable, and (A) is false.

*** Retreat to Commitment Retreat to Commitment by Bartley - AbeBooks and Retreat to Commitment: Bartley, III: 9780812691276: Amazon.com: Books

 

Support via Patreon – https://www.patreon.com/jedleahenry

Support via PayPal – https://www.paypal.me/jrleahenry

Website – The Popperian Podcast — Jed Lea-Henry

Libsyn – The Popperian Podcast (libsyn.com)

Youtube – The Popperian Podcast - YouTube

Twitter – https://twitter.com/jedleahenry

RSS - https://popperian-podcast.libsyn.com/rss

*** Underlying artwork by Arturo Espinosa