#55 - Dean Ball x Daniel Kokotajlo Anti-Debate - Should GOVERNMENTS or MARKETS control AI?

Advanced AI is coming. Is it time for the government to step in and regulate? Or is it better in the hands of the market and tech CEOs? Or is there a more nuanced way to think about this topic entirely? 

Welcome to the ANTI-DEBATE. It's debating, but with a positive-sum twist! My guests today are two of the most qualified people on either side this topic: former Trump AI advisor Dean Ball, and OpenAI researcher-turned-whistleblower Daniel Kokotajlo. Can they find a way to bridge their differences and find a synthesis that satisfies all their concerns? What are their thoughts on the Anthropic vs Department of War & Pete Hegseth feud? Can they align on alignment? 

Chapters:

00:00 - Intro and Anthropic vs Department of War feud

3:42 - Daniel’s Story

4:34 - Dean’s Story

6:52 - Opening Statements

19:54 - Rebuttals

25:45 - Free Debate

36:32 - Steelmanning

45:40 - Red-teaming

51:38 - Synthesis

1:17:30 - Closing Statements

This video was made in collaboration with Stephanie Lepp of  ⁨@synthesis_media⁩ who is the brains behind this open-source Anti-Debate format. Huge thanks to her for helping me bring this conversation to life. Go check out the Anti-Debate website below, and create your own! 

Links:

♾️ Anti-Debate Project: https://anti-debate.org

♾️ Daniel's AI 2027 Futures: https://ai-2027.com

♾️ Dean's Hyperdimensional Blog: https://www.hyperdimensional.co/

♾️ Light Haven filming location: https://www.lighthaven.space

♾️ Synthesis Media: https://www.synthesismedia.org

♾️ Hoover Institution: https://www.hoover.org

♾️ Anthropic vs Department of War: https://www.anthropic.com

Credits:

♾️ Hosted by Liv Boeree

♾️ Idea & Production: Stephanie Lepp  @synthesis_media  

♾️ Video Editing by Luca de Vico

♾️ Intro edit by Perry Sinclair

The Win-Win Podcast:

Poker champion Liv Boeree takes to the interview chair to tease apart the complexities of one of the most fundamental parts of human nature: competition. Liv is joined by top philosophers, gamers, artists, technologists, CEOs, scientists, politicians and more to understand how competition manifests in their world, and how to change seemingly win-lose systems into Win-Wins.

Podcast links:

♾️ Website: https://www.winwinpodcast.com/ 

♾️ Youtube:   https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWgq0OZMtwtOIyMsVM_vksqdfWcM-b68S 

♾️ Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/03bGVUaFZmJUmEvSHNDPdI?si=64379cc23696454f 

♾️ Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/win-win-with-liv-boeree/id1724791350 

♾️ Pocketcast: https://play.pocketcasts.com/podcasts/7f708340-d17c-013b-f46e-0acc26574db2 

#winwinpodcast #AIGovernance #technology