Do Colleges Care About Both ACT and SAT? Cracking the Code with Shellee Howard and Jackie Pollina

In this insightful and comprehensive discussion, Shelley Howard hosts Jackie Pollina, founder of J&J Test Prep and No BS SAT Prep, to explore the critical role of test preparation in high school and college admissions. Jackie shares her entrepreneurial journey from a stressed high school test-taker to a passionate business owner who creates modern, digestible test prep approaches. They emphasize the ongoing importance of standardized testing, even in a test-optional world, highlighting how strong scores enhance admission chances and secure substantial scholarships. The conversation debunks common myths around the SAT and ACT, recommending personalized diagnostic testing to determine the best fit for each student. They also provide detailed guidance on the various test prep formats—private tutoring, intensive classes, and crash courses—tailored to different goals and preparation timelines, underscoring the need for strategic, multi-test preparation over time. Additionally, the dialogue touches on AP exam support, summer prep advantages, and the importance of proactive parental involvement. Real-life experiences reinforce the long-term impact of solid test strategies, demonstrating how early preparation benefits students well beyond admission, even into professional exams like the MCAT. Finally, they encourage parents to engage actively with test prep resources to maximize scholarship opportunities and optimize college readiness.

Highlights

• Jackie Pollina founded J&J Test Prep with a mission to make test preparation modern, relatable, and manageable.
• Test-optional admissions still favor students with strong standardized test scores for admission chances and merit scholarships.
• Diagnostic testing is essential to decide whether a student should take the SAT or ACT based on individual strengths and timing.
• Effective test prep requires at least eight weeks and ideally multiple test attempts for significant score improvement.
• Strategic test prep can dramatically increase scores, influencing college admission and scholarship opportunities.
• Summer is the optimal season for test prep due to fewer academic distractions and more available study time.
• Test preparation is a skill that supports future professional exams, making early preparation an investment beyond college admissions.

Key Insights

• Test Prep as a Long-Term Skill: Jackie and Shelley stress that testing is not a one-time hurdle but a lifelong skill essential for careers requiring professional exams like the LSAT, MCAT, or boards. This reframing helps parents and students view test prep as a beneficial investment rather than a temporary chore. Developing strategies early fosters confidence and competence for decades ahead, reinforcing the importance of embracing test prep rather than avoiding it.
• The Nuances of Test-Optional Policies: While many students celebrate test-optional admissions by skipping tests, data shows that students with strong scores tend to be admitted more often and awarded more merit-based aid. Colleges remain flexible but often encourage submissions. This “test-optional” not “test-irrelevant” distinction is vital for families to understand—relying solely on test-optional policies can be risky if future admissions cycles change policies unexpectedly.
• Customized Test Selection via Diagnostics: Deciding between the SAT and ACT cannot be done on surface-level preferences or perceived subject strengths. Diagnostic exams provide a data-driven approach to uncover a student’s natural aptitude, timing skills, and question-type preferences. This personalized method ensures students invest effort in the test most aligned with their abilities, optimizing their potential outcomes and reducing unnecessary frustration.
• Time Investment is Key for Meaningful Score Gains: Test prep is not a quick fix. Significant improvements (e.g., 200+ points on the SAT) require sustained, individualized preparation often through private tutoring. More moderate improvements can be obtained in structured classes. Crash courses serve as last-minute boosters but cannot replace comprehensive prep. This underscores the importance of planning ahead, managing expectations, and resisting the “one-and-done” test mindset.
• Scholarships Depend Heavily on Scores: Test scores play a critical role beyond admission—they are often a primary factor in awarding merit scholarships, which can substantially reduce the financial burden of college. Shelley’s real-world story of her son’s 300-point SAT improvement illustrates how strategic prep can be a financial game-changer, converting a generic state school opportunity into elite college admission, with profound long-term benefits.
• Summer Offers a Strategic Advantage: Utilizing summer breaks for test prep takes advantage of reduced academic stress and increased availability to focus on study. This timing allows students to absorb material effectively, avoid burnout during the school year, and be prepared for fall test dates. Summer prep is a smart, balanced approach rather than forcing test prep during already demanding school months.
• Parental Support and Realistic Expectations Are Vital: Students often dread test prep; motivation can be low. Hence, parental involvement is crucial to facilitate scheduling, advocate for professional help such as test strategists, and nurture a growth-oriented mindset around testing. Being a proactive, informed parent translates into better prep options, well-timed testing, and ultimately superior outcomes for the student.

Conclusion
The conversation between Shelley Howard and Jackie Pollina serves as a valuable resource for families navigating the complexities of college test preparation. It offers evidence-based guidance on choosing tests, appropriate timing, and tailored prep formats, while also underscoring the financial and long-term personal benefits of mastering test-taking skills. Parents are empowered to approach test prep proactively and strategically, ensuring their teens maximize college admission and scholarship opportunities, and set the stage for future academic resilience.

Connect with Shellee Howard:

Website: www.collegereadyplan.com/
YouTube: www.youtube.com/channel/UCr_WodPHDfSWEbiPdsRDbyQ
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/collegereadyplan/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/college-ready/
Email: [email protected]

Connect with Jacqueline Pollina

Website: www.jjtestprep.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/jackie.pollina.sat.prep/
                   www.facebook.com/jjtestprep
Instagram: @jjtestprep
TikTok: @testpreptips
Email: [email protected]

🎁 Episode Gift & Contact

 

🎓 College Planning Support for Parents
Want help organizing next steps and avoiding costly college mistakes?

 

📘 Workbook Gift:
https://go.collegereadyplan.com/podcast-gift-workbook

 

🤝 Interested in Collaborating with College Ready?
Email Julienne at [email protected]