E657 - How to Avoid the Common Mistakes Made in a Podcast Pitch

Episode 657 - How to Avoid the Common Mistakes Made in a Podcast Pitch

In this episode of The How To Podcast Series, host Dave cuts through the noise of podcast pitching with his signature no-nonsense wisdom, drawing from over 2,200 episodes—including 1,000+ interviews—to expose the pitfalls that doom most guest pitches straight to the spam folder. He shares cringe-worthy real-life examples, like PR agents addressing him as "Chris" or "Rachel" despite claiming they've "listened to the show," or AI-generated emails awkwardly dropping the full, rarely spoken podcast title. These red flags reveal pitches that feel automated, soulless, and oblivious to the host's world. Dave flips the script to what works: pitches that honor the show, its audience, and the host's time, turning cold outreach into genuine connections.

At the heart of bad pitches? Self-centeredness—leading with sales goals like "I need to sell my book" or "I want leads," firing off generic templates with un-replaced brackets ("[Insert Host Name]"), or suggesting wildly off-topic guests, such as an astroturf expert for a podcasting show. Other killers include skipping the show entirely (no listening = no clue about fit), fake personalization that screams ChatGPT, shotgun blasts to every inbox, vague topic ideas, credential-dumping over listener outcomes, and ignoring submission forms. Hosts, Dave notes, are drowning in this junk from bots and lazy PR, so standing out means proving you've done the homework.

What do hosts crave? Proof you've listened (mention a specific episode), a crystal-clear topic fit with 2-3 fresh angles that fill a content gap, and a reason the audience wins—practical takeaways, stories they relate to, not your resume. Sweeten it by making booking effortless: attach headshots, bios, one-sheets, and promo assets upfront. Dave contrasts a "bad pitch" bombast ("I'm a bestselling author... here's my calendar") with a winning one ("Hi Dave, loved your episode on X—here's how [topic] helps listeners [result], with takeaways and an outline if it fits"). For laughs, he amps up the absurdity: an "hamster astrologer" hawking pigeon EI startups vs. a focused, fun pitch tying weird expertise to resilience.

Key takeaway for podcasters: Ditch the me-focused, automated spam—craft short, human, audience-first pitches that respect the host's chaos. Show up warm, useful, and relationship-driven, and you'll book more spots. Your story deserves airtime; give it the pitch that earns it. Head to HowToPodcast.com for guest prep help, share your pitch nightmares via SpeakPipe, or take their listener survey to shape future episodes. Evergreen advice like this keeps drawing listeners back—even to Episode 1.

____

Helping Podcasters Everyday! 

https://howtopodcast.ca/
We would love to hear from you - here is our listener survey!

https://forms.gle/GbrFv9DGszV8N4PW6