F1 General | Joe Unplugged | 172 | The Fantasy Grid: Which Car Era Best Reveals Driver Talent?

Listener Drew asks: if you could put every current Formula 1 driver in the same generation of car for one race, which era would you choose? It sounds like a fun hypothetical — until you try to answer it.

In this episode, Dick and Sabrina bring the question to Joe Saward, who has watched the sport evolve across four decades and has little patience for cross-era comparisons that can't be proven. Dick makes the case for the late 1980s turbo era — 1,500 horsepower from a 1.5-liter engine, terrifying to drive, with safety that would be unacceptable today. Joe pushes back with a principle he credits to Niki Lauda: the best driver is simply the fastest one, and the truly great ones consistently get more out of the car than the car is willing to give.

The conversation expands into what IndyCar results actually tell us about F1 readiness, what Colton Herta's Formula 2 campaign will really reveal, why balance of performance regulations undermine the entire premise of the sport, and what makes Formula 1 the top gun of motorsport in a way that no other series can claim. Joe and Dick ultimately agree on the one thing that holds across every era: true talent finds a way to show itself regardless of the machinery.

Check out Joe online: 

• JSBM Newsletter 
• Grand Prix+
• The Green Notebook 

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Have episode feedback or ideas? Drop them a line at: [email protected]

Follow 2 Guys, A Girl, and F1 on Instagram.

Check out Dick's karting documentary, Power Drive Vegas.
Interested in Dick's return to kart racing? Check out, Begin Again.

Thanks to all who have become members of the 2 Guys, A Girl, and F1 via our “Buy me A Coffee” page. This community is growing because of you.  To become a member, click here.

Like the 2 Guys, A Girl, and F1 background music? It's "An Adventure Called Life" by Score Squad. It's available for purchase at Premium Beat.  Use referral code SNSAEDUB at checkout to get 25% off your first purchase.

2025 Sound Engineers: Paul Douglas and Elena Richey