Loading...
Loading...

Myanmar’s rare earth deposits have drawn international attention, but multiple challenges stand in the way of translating this potential into a stable supply chain.
An analysis by Prashanth Parameswaran. Read the full report here.
📚 Explore all GIS Reports
📝 Read the weekly comments from Prince Michael of Liechtenstein
🔔 Stay updated on the latest reports and analysis: LinkedIn & X
📬 Sign up for our weekly newsletter or subscribe directly on LinkedIn
I want you to take a second and just think about the technology you rely on every single day.
Oh, yeah. Like your smartphone, your laptop.
Right. Exactly. Or maybe the tech you're planning to buy soon, like an electric vehicle,
or, you know, the high-tech magnets inside all your devices. Maybe even the precision guidance
systems that keep global shipping lanes running. Yeah. It's everywhere. It is. And there's this
incredibly sleek, kind of futuristic expectation we have about all of this green and next-generation tech.
Oh, totally. We picture like sterile labor tortoises.
Christine factories. Yeah. And this clean, renewable horizon.
Exactly. But what have I told you that the secret linchpin-like, the absolute foundation holding
this entire global tech boom together, is a country currently mired in a brutal civil war?
It's pretty jarring when you think about it. It really is. I'm talking about me and more.
So welcome to today's deep dive. It's a striking contradiction, honestly,
and it really forces a reality check for all of us because we intuitively associate these advanced
technologies with a clean, progressive future. But when you trace the supply chain all the way back
to the dirt, the reality of where these foundational materials originate is, well, it's anything
but clean. And it is certainly not stable. Not at all. And that is exactly our mission for today.
We are unpacking a highly timely and credibly eye-opening report from GIS reports.
Yeah. This was put together by geopolitical analyst Prashant Paramus Warren.
Right. And it's in for publication on March 17, 2026.
And the goal here is to really, you know, cut through the noise of complex global geopolitics.
It can get pretty dense. It really can. We need to understand exactly how a fractured,
historically isolated nation has somehow become the absolute center of a global tug of war
over critical minerals. And frankly, we need to understand why that shiny,
new green tech you are so proud of might have a surprisingly dark origin story.
Okay, let's unpack this. Let's do it. To really grasp the global stakes here,
we first have to understand the sheer mind-boggling scale of what is buried in Myanmar's soil.
Right. Because when most people think about rare earth minerals,
they immediately think of China. And for good reason, right?
China currently accounts for about 60% of the global rare earth mining output.
Wow. 60%. Yeah. And when it comes to the processing side of things,
actually turning those raw, muddy minerals into the refined magnet materials we use,
China controls more than 90% of the global market.
Wait, hang on. The math doesn't add up there.
How so?
If China already dominates 60% of the world's mining,
why are we talking about Myanmar? I mean, why are they relevant
if Beijing essentially holds them monopoly?
Well, because Myanmar is the silent giant in this equation, specifically for the materials
that matter most. Okay.
The analysis shows that Myanmar is actually second only to China in terms of rare earth use
specifically in magnets. Oh, wow. Second in the world.
Yeah. Roughly two thirds of China's annual imports of rare earth elements come directly
from Myanmar. That is massive. It's a billion dollar supply chain.
And it is centered almost entirely on what are called heavy rare earth elements,
specifically elements like dysprosium and terbium.
Okay. I've heard those names thrown around in tech circles,
but break down the mechanics for sure.
What makes heavy rare earths so irreplaceable? I mean, why can't we just use standard
magnetic materials? It really just comes down to basic physics and heat.
Heat. Yeah. So if you think about a standard magnet,
it's magnetic field is created by atoms aligning in a specific direction.
Right. Like in high school science class.
Exactly. But when that magnet gets hot, like say, inside an electric vehicle motor that's
spinning at thousands of revolutions per minute or inside a massive wind turbine baking in the sun.
Exactly. When it gets hot, that atomic alignment starts to shake loose.
The magnet essentially loses its grip and it demagnetizes.
So the engine just fails precisely. Heavy rare earths like dysprosium act like a molecular superglue.
A molecular superglue. I like that. Yeah. When you mix them into the magnet's alloy,
they lock that atomic structure in place. It allows the magnet to operate at extremely high
temperatures without losing its magnetic properties. Look how they see. You simply cannot build a
functional electric vehicle or a reliable wind turbine without them. They are completely irreplaceable.
So to look at this geopolitically, I mean, it's like a global bakery where China gets all the
credit for baking the cake, but Myanmar is quietly supplying all the essential hard-defined flower.
That is a perfect way to put it. But again, I have to push back here. If China has its own vast
reserves and they do 60% of the mining, why rely on an unstable war zone across the border?
Yeah. Why not just dig it up themselves? That is the critical question. Over recent years,
China's own domestic mining activity for these specific heavy rare earths has drastically declined.
Really? Why? Well, Beijing looked at the severe environmental degradation happening within
its own borders and they implemented much tighter environmental and industry regulations
domestically. Oh, so they essentially cleaned up their own backyard by throwing the trash over
the fence? That is exactly what happened. They tightened the rules at home, which basically
resulted in outsourcing the heavy, messy, environmentally catastrophic work across their southern
border into Myanmar. Unbelievable. Yeah. They keep the high-value, high-tech processing industry safe
within China, but they let Myanmar handle the unregulated toxic extraction, which leads us directly
to the reality on the ground in Myanmar. Because if you have a billion dollar extraction industry
supplying the most critical component of the global tech boom, you would naturally assume that
Myanmar's central government is sitting on a gold mine building immense national wealth.
You would think so, yeah. But the geography of this tells a completely different story.
It is far more fragmented and incredibly volatile. Right. If you look at the map,
provided in the GIS sources, these mining sites aren't spread evenly across the country
and they aren't near the capital. No, that's at all. They were clustered right up against the
Chinese border. We were talking about places like Chippewy Township and Pangwa, deep in Kachin
and I want to pause here for you listening. Because we are dealing with politically charged ongoing
civil war dynamics between the military, Shanta and various rebel groups, we want to make it
absolutely clear to you listening. We are not taking sides or endorsing any political viewpoints here.
We are strictly and impartially reporting the facts on the ground as outlined in the GIS source
material. Absolutely. And the facts on the ground regarding that control are completely counterintuitive.
How so? Well, the military junta, which took power in the coup back in 2021, actually controls
very few of these lucrative mineral deposits. Wow. It's wild to think about a military government
that is effectively locked out of its own most valuable resource. It is. Instead, these billion
dollar deposits are exploited primarily by ethnic armed groups. Okay. In Kachin state,
where the bulk of this rare earth extraction is happening, the territory is controlled by the
Kachin Independence Organization or the KIO. They function almost like an autonomous entity in that
region and they have been exporting these resources directly across the border to China for processing
for a long time. And the KIO isn't the only player in this space, right? No. The data points to
significant rare earth mining expanding further south into Shant State. Okay. So a different region
entirely. Yeah. And that area is controlled by different ethnic armed groups, most notably the
United West State Army, the UWSA. Right. And to give you some context, the UWSA isn't just a
rag tag rebel group. They are widely considered by analysts to be the most capable, well-funded,
and well-equipped among all the armed groups in Myanmar. They operate what is essentially a state
within a state, complete with their own weapons manufacturing. So instead of a unified national
export strategy, you have heavily armed non-state actors running a decentralized billion dollar
global supply chain. Yeah. What's fascinating here is how the specific dynamic, you know, armed
groups running local economies isn't entirely new, even if the sheer scale of the rare earth boom
is unprecedented. What do you mean? Well, the Myanmar military has a decades-old history of negotiating
specific ceasefire arrangements with these ethnic armies. The mechanics of these deals are essentially
the military allows these groups to pursue their own highly lucrative economic activities,
like mining or logging in their respective territories. Oh, I see. And in return. In exchange,
the armed groups agree to a cessation of hostilities. This allows the central military to retain overall
political power in the capital without having to fight a war on a dozen fronts simultaneously.
So it's a fragile balancing act built on a mountain of dysprosia. Exactly. And here's where it gets
really interesting, because the fact that non-state actors control a critical global resource
creates a massive vulnerability, but also an opportunity for world superpowers.
Absolutely. I mean, it's like a lawless gold rush. Or it's like a toll booth on the world's most
important technological highway. But the toll booth is operated by a heavily armed neighborhood
watch that the actual national government is completely powerless to evict. That is a perfect
way to visualize it. And the broader geopolitical panic here is intense. Oh, I'm sure.
Countries around the world, especially the United States, are terrified of this exact setup.
Because of the supply chain vulnerability. Exactly. They look at China's 90% processing monopoly
combined with this unstable pipeline from Myanmar and realize the supply chain could easily be
weaponized for coercion. Right. If Beijing suddenly decides to restrict exports of these refined
magnet materials, like during a diplomatic dispute, for example, yeah, it could instantly paralyze
entire sectors of the US and European economies from defense manufacturing to the entire green
energy transition, which is why they desperately want to diversify. They need a backup plan.
Everyone is looking for alternative sources. They are. And this urgency ties into a much larger
regional economic trend that analysts refer to as resource nationalism or downstreaming.
Okay, break the mechanics of that down force. What does it actually mean for a country
to downstream its resources? It basically means moving up the economic value chain. Okay.
Historically, many developing nations would just let foreign companies come in dig up their
raw dirt and export it for pennies on the dollar. Meanwhile, the foreign companies made billions
refining it abroad. Right. Classic exploitation. Exactly. Resource nationalism is the idea that
these governments are no longer content with that deal. Countries across Asia, like Indonesia,
with nickel, are asserting greater control over their natural resources. They want a bigger piece
of the pie. Yeah. They are passing laws, forcing foreign companies to build the expensive processing
plants locally. They want to capture the massive profit margins of the refined product, not just
sell the raw ore. Okay. That makes sense on a macroeconomic level. Okay. But let's apply this
directly to the US and Myanmar. Sure. Because if the US and others are absolutely desperate to counter
China's dominance, and Myanmar has the second largest functional supply of these critical magnet
minerals, why don't they just swoop in? It's a logical question. Right. I mean, why don't the US
or European tech giants bypass China entirely and make direct deals with the junta or even the
armed groups to secure their own supply? Because the reality of operating in Myanmar right now
makes that geographically and politically impossible. The logistical hurdles are just
instrumentable. First, you have an active ongoing civil war. Yeah. That means there are no secure
land routes and certainly no secure sea routes to reliably get thousands of tons of minerals
out of the country to the west. Right. I mean, you can't exactly run a highly coordinated fleet
of corporate semi-trucks through an unpredictable combat zone. Exactly. Add to that the fact that
these mines are located an incredibly remote contested and rugged mountainous terrain. Right.
But the most glaring roadblock is the lack of infrastructure. There is zero advanced rare
earth processing capability inside Myanmar. Because, as we established, China does all the complex
high-tech processing right across the border. Yes. Myanmar literally only has the capability to
dig it out of the ground. Right. Furthermore, if the US tried to bypass the central government and
make a direct diplomatic or economic deal with a group like the KIO, it would severely complicate
the KIO's existing vital ties with China. And they wouldn't want to risk that. No, because for
the KIO, China isn't just a casual trading partner. It is a massive, looming geographic and
economic neighbor that carries far more immediate weight and leverage than the distant United States.
So the west is effectively locked out by geography, a total lack of infrastructure,
and the chaotic realities of the Civil War. Exactly. Which leaves this entire operation
completely unregulated, serving a single master across the border. And that brings us to the
devastating on-the-ground reality. Change a grim. Because beyond the high-level geopolitical
chess game and the billions of dollars changing hands, there is a horrifying, tangible,
physical toll for the people of Myanmar. There really is. The extraction process for heavy
rare earths is notoriously toxic, even when it is conducted under the most strict modern
environmental regulations. Right. So in a completely unregulated militant run environment,
the process is catastrophic. Let's explain the actual mechanism of this to everyone listening,
because it's not just guys with pickaxes. Oh, no, not at all. We are talking about a process
called in situ leaching. The GIS source files included this striking imagery of the aftermath,
but the way they get there is brutal. Miners literally drill deep holes into the side of a lush,
living mountain. Yeah. Then they pump thousands of gallons of a highly toxic chemical,
usually ammonium sulfate directly into the earth. It's terrible. The chemicals dissolve the
soil from the inside out. That separates those tightly bound rare earth elements from the dirt.
The mountain is essentially liquefied from within, and the resulting toxic sludge is pumped back
to the surface. It is a devastatingly efficient way to extract the minerals, but the environmental
cost is absolute. I can't even imagine. That striking imagery you mentioned perfectly encapsulates
the grim reality. You see these sprawling, unregulated mining sites carved out of what used to
be vibrant forests. Just totally barren. The earth is completely stripped bare, deeply scarred,
and right in the middle of these vast excavated craters are these stagnant, unnatural looking pools
of water. Oh, wow. They aren't lakes either. They are chemical runoff pits filled with the toxic
byproducts of that leaching process. Because there are absolutely no environmental or labor
standards being enforced by these armed groups, the consequences just cascade. Exactly. We are
looking at rampant deforestation just to clear the land for the drilling, massive soil erosion.
Because the structural integrity of the mountain sides has been chemically dissolved,
which leads to deadly landslides. And it is a complete and utter loss of biodiversity.
Absolutely. And we cannot ignore the human element here either. The public health impacts on the
local populations living near these sites are horrific. I'm sure the water supply alone. Exactly.
Those toxic chemicals without any protective containment liners or water treatment facilities
leach directly into the topsoil in the groundwater. Right. And the local communities rely on those
exact water sources for drinking and agriculture. And if we connect this to the bigger picture,
this isn't just a localized tragedy contained within Myanmar's borders anymore, is it? Because the
geography of rivers doesn't care about national borders. That is a crucial point. If we connect this
to the bigger picture, the environmental damage has already spilled over. Specifically, the severe
water contamination linked to the mining activities down in Shand State has literally flowed down
river directly across the border into neighboring Thailand. Wow. That fundamentally changes the
geopolitical math. Thailand isn't just a bystander watching a civil war next door anymore.
No, they are essentially being forced to drink the toxic runoff of the global energy transition.
How was Bangkok responding to this? With intense diplomatic criticism and growing alarm,
Thailand is now being forced to step out of its traditional diplomatic comfort zone to position
itself as a leading regional manager of Myanmar's spillover crises. Right. Because it affects them
directly now. Exactly. Their own agricultural security and the health of their border populations
are directly threatened by this unregulated mining boom. It is the ultimate
tragic paradox. I mean, think about it. You listening might go out and purchase a state-of-the-art
electric vehicle. Yeah. And you are doing it because you want to reduce your carbon footprint,
you want to cut emissions, and you want to help save the environment. Right. It feels like the ethical
choice. But the physical motor propelling that car down the highway is held together by magnets
born from the complete unregulated ecological destruction of a mountain in Myanmar.
It is a textbook definition of the resource curse. Explain that turn real quick.
It's where having an abundance of incredibly valuable natural resources actually
undermines a country's prosperity, stability, and environment rather than elevating it.
It's a dark irony. The very resources that the globe desperately needs to achieve a green transition
are actively fueling localized environmental collapse and funding armed conflict.
Yeah. So synthesizing all this chaos, the civil war, the environmental destruction,
the geopolitical standoff, the downstreaming, where did the situation actually go from here?
It's a tough question. Walk us through the future scenarios laid out in the GIS analysis,
because they map out three very distinct possibilities for Myanmar's rare earth sector.
Right. Yeah. The analyst breaks it down by likelihood.
So let's start with what is considered the most likely scenario.
Okay. In this outcome, the status quo largely holds.
We see a continuation of narrow short-term economic deals.
The underlying structural problems remain entirely unsolved.
So, business is usual, but perhaps with higher stakes.
Essentially, yes. The KIO and other armed groups will likely leverage the soaring global
demand for these rare earth to renegotiate better prices and more favorable terms with their
Chinese buyers. Right. Because they know their strategic values increasing.
Exactly. We might also see nearby countries like India attempt to negotiate limited,
localized deals given their geographic proximity and their own need for minerals.
But major US involvement. It remains highly unlikely due to those severe
logistical and political constraints we discussed earlier.
So the money keeps flowing to the armed groups, the environment continues to degrade,
and the civil conflict just grinds on.
Unfortunately, yes.
Okay. What about the second scenario?
What does a pass towards stability actually look like?
Well, the less likely scenario involves a total recalibration of the mining sector.
The goal would be to create broadly distributed economic benefits for the entirety of Myanmar,
rather than just enriching specific local armed groups and Chinese processing firms.
That sounds incredibly optimistic. It is.
What are the actual mechanics of achieving that in a fractured state?
It would require a monumental shift, specifically a transition away from the current military junta
to a functional civilian representative government.
That's a huge hurdle right there.
Right. And it doesn't stop at just changing the leadership.
You would need to unite the central government, the ethnic armed groups,
and local communities to create what analysts call an enabling ecosystem.
An enabling ecosystem, meaning what?
It means undertaking serious complex dialogues on federalism,
indigenous land rights, and establishing a robust constitutional framework that dictates
exactly how mining revenues are shared nationally.
Basically, you have to build a functional, regulated,
inclusive state from the ground up all while sitting on a billion dollar gold mine
that everyone wants a piece of.
Exactly. Which is precisely why the scenario is categorized as less likely.
The political will and the trust required between these warring factions simply do not exist right now.
Right. That makes sense.
And that brings us to the third scenario.
The least likely scenario is a complete and sudden rollback of rebel mining operations.
Full stop.
A full stop to the extraction of rare earths in these border regions.
Why is that the least likely?
I mean, given that they're at war, wouldn't the military junta want to
completely shut down their enemy's primary funding source?
They absolutely would want to, but they simply do not have the operational control
or the military power to enforce it in those rugged border territories.
Right.
The UWSA and the KIO are just too deeply entrenched.
So how would a halt even happen then?
The only way a full halt realistically happens is through a combination of severe,
internal, and external pressures.
Like what?
There would have to be an overwhelming domestic backlash from the local populations
suffering from the environmental destruction combined with intense, sustained,
regional pressure.
Like from Thailand.
Exactly.
Thailand threatening major economic or diplomatic consequences over the cross-border water
contamination.
Only then might the armed groups be forced to halt operations to preserve their own political
standing and regional alliances.
Wow.
So what does this all mean?
When you take a step back and synthesize all these moving parts, the
billion dollar Chinese processing monopolies that heavily armed rebel groups
acting as toll booths, the mountains being dissolved into toxic lakes and the global panic
over securing supply chains, what is the core insight you should walk away with today?
I think the fundamental takeaway is that supply chains are never just abstract lines drawn
on a global map.
Right.
They are deeply, inextricably embedded in the political, social, and environmental realities
of the dirt they originate from.
You cannot separate the future of global, clean technology from the messy, violent reality of
Myanmar's civil conflict.
Myanmar isn't just some distant country, occasionally making the evening news for its tragic
ongoing civil war, it is quite literally the fragile,
unregulated, and highly contested engine room of our modern technological world.
It is supplying the literal magnetic pull that keeps the entire
global green energy transition moving forward.
But it is doing so at an incredibly dark and devastating cost to its own people and its own land.
Exactly.
So the next time you look at a piece of high-tech gear or read an optimistic article about the
booming sales of electric vehicles, I want you to remember the complex, hidden web that made
it possible.
Yeah.
Remember the disprosium holding the motors together, remember the Kachin independence organization,
the dissolved mountain sides, and the high-stakes geopolitics playing out in the shadows of the jungle.
And there is one final crucial implication to consider here looking forward.
Oops, that.
We are currently in this frantic, global race to transition away from fossil fuels,
relying heavily on these rare earths to save our climate.
Right, it's an existential race.
But if the extraction of these materials requires the complete toxic destruction of local ecosystems
in places like Myanmar, what happens when those regions become entirely uninhabitable?
That is a staggering thought.
If Myanmar's environment collapses entirely due to unregulated mining,
will the global push for green energy inadvertently trigger the next massive wave of regional
climate refugees?
Wow.
It forces us to ask, are the very technological tools we are building to save the planet
simultaneously making large parts of it completely unlivable?
Let that sink in.

Unconventional Knowledge by GIS

Unconventional Knowledge by GIS

Unconventional Knowledge by GIS
