
Mike's Minute: Why is National not releasing reports on race-based issues?
About this episode
You do wonder if National have an agenda pre-election over race-based issues.
The Waitangi Tribunal review is on Tama Potaka's desk and has been for a while.
It hasn’t gone to Cabinet. Why not?
The report into what they call MAPAS (the Maori and Pacific Admissions Scheme) for medical school at Auckland and Otago university was a coalition deal between Act and National to review it.
They have done it. It's on Associate Health minister Matt Doocey's desk.
Has it gone to Cabinet? No.
Why?
Could it be National aren't all that gripped by race-based issues and don’t want to rock the boat before polling day?
The medical school programme is a scam. It's defended by the universities because they want the gap closed in terms of race representation in medical studies.
In simple terms if you are a Maori or Pacific Islander, your entry to medical school is easier than if you are not. That is indisputably discrimination.
What makes it worse is access to medical school for non-Maori or Pacific Islanders is extraordinarily high.
You need a score into the very high 90's to even get close. There has been much debate over the years as to whether that actually produces great doctors or not.
As a result Auckland take a slightly different approach to Otago over admissions, but the truth remains race gives you an easier pathway.
Their defence also suggests that once in you still have to achieve, no matter who you are and that they also run a rural programme that favours students from regional backgrounds.
My argument is race and geography should play no role. What I want in a doctor is competence and professionalism. Do they know what they are doing?
My GP's have been women, Asian, Indian, male, British, Irish, older and younger. None of it mattered.
Some were quite obviously good, some weren't. Their medical acumen was, and is, what I'm interested in. I assume it's even more relevant by the time you are on a surgery table getting cut open.
It will be interesting to see what the report says. I find it hard to believe the conclusion isn't inevitable i.e race is discrimination, and this Government promised that sort of thing would stop.
So, where is the report? Why isn't it public?
LISTEN ABOVE
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Get every episode summarized
Each time The Mike Hosking Breakfast publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.
Email me new episodesFree for 3 shows. No card needed.
Hosts & guests
Transcript ready
50 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.
Full transcript
The Mike Hosking Breakfast — Mike's Minute: Why is National not releasing reports on race-based issues?. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.
Enjoy big savings with Red Hot deals at Vons and Albertsons. This week at Vons and Albertsons, baby back pork ribs are 299 per pound with membership where applicable limit 3 racks. And ballpark hot dogs or hamburger buns 8 count are 299 with digital coupon. Plus personal seedless watermelons or canelope are 199 each with digital coupon. Enjoy fresh and delicious savings for every meal. Hurry in, these deals won't last. Visit vonsoralbertsons.com for more deals and ways to save. Get over there, you do wonder if the net has an agenda pre-election over race-based issues. The White Henget Tribunal review is on-term a post-arch as desk has been for a while that hasn't gone to cabinet. Why not? The report into what they call Mappas, the Maori-Pacific admissions scheme for Med School at Auckland and Otago University, was a coalition deal between acting national to review it. Now they've done so. It's on the Associate Health Minister Matt Ducey's desk has it gone to cabinet?
No, it hasn't. Why not? Could it be the net's art all that gripped by race-based issues and don't want to rock the boat before polling day? Now the Med School program is a scam, of course. It's defended by the universities because they want to close that gap in terms of race. The representation of medical studies. Now in simple terms, if you're a Maori or Pacific Islander, your entry to Med School is easier than if you are not. That is indisputably discrimination. What makes it worse is access to Med School for non-Marion Pacific Islanders is, of course, extraordinarily high. You need to score something in the very, very high 90s to even get close. Now there's been much debate over the years as to whether that actually produces great doctors or not, and as it turns out Auckland as a result take a slightly different approach to a targo over admissions. But be that as it may, the truth remains, race gives you an easier pathway. The defence also suggests that once in you still have to achieve no matter who you are, and that they also run a rural program that favour students from regional backgrounds.
Now, my argument is race and geography should play no role. What I want in a doctor is competence, of course. Competence and professionalism. Do they know what they are doing? My GPs over the years have been women, Asian, Indian, male, British, Irish, older, younger, none of that mattered. Some were quite obviously good, some were not. The medical acumen was and is what I'm interested in. I assume it's even more relevant by the time you're on a surgery table about to get cut open. It'll be interesting to see what the report actually says if we ever see it. I mean, I find it hard to believe the conclusion isn't inevitable. I.E. race is discrimination, and this government promised that sort of thing would stop. So where's the report? And why isn't it public? The Mike Harsking Breakfast, 6-9 weekdays on NewsTalk's IP.
More episodes
More from The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Lisa Levy: Inati Co-Owner on the impact of the Michelin Star on their restaurant
The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Full Show Podcast: 08 September 2026
The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Simon Kebbell: Port of Tauranga Chief Financial Officer on the Stella Passage de...
The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Annie Dundas: Auckland Unlimited Destination Director on the Government investin...
The Mike Hosking Breakfast
