Night Watch: A Pastor, A Death, and A Shocking FBI Investigation

This is Crime House.

To the outside world, Micah Miller's marriage to a South Carolina pastor appeared rooted

in faith, but after her death, investigators now allege it was a nightmare, marked by

grooming, control, surveillance, and pure fear.

Welcome to Nightwatch on Crime House 24-7.

I'm your host Katie Ring, and together we'll be following the cases making headlines

now, where justice is still unfolding.

Follow us wherever you're listening, and if you want at free episodes, subscribe

to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts.

Plus subscribe to our YouTube channel at NightwatchPod.

This episode discusses an active criminal case.

The information we share is based on what's publicly available at the time of recording,

and may change as new evidence comes to light.

We aim to inform not to decide, go, or innocence, so everyone mentioned is presumed innocent

until proven guilty in a court of law.

On this show, we spend a lot of time focused on details, because details can change how

you understand a case, and in travel, details change how you understand a place.

For travel that gets the details right, visit gocalette.com slash podcast, and use offer

code travel26 to get $200 off select collect explorations tours.

Collette's small group explorations tours are designed with that same focus on details.

You're led by experts and locals who know the destination inside and out, and groups stay

small, with an average of just 19 travelers, so the experience feels more personal.

You might take part in a century's old tea ceremony in Japan, guided by the meaning

and tradition behind every step, or explore Southern Africa on expert led safaris that

spend multiple days on game drives, giving you time to truly understand the landscape

and wildlife.

With Collette, you get immersive travel bill on thoughtful planning, local expertise,

and more than a century of experience behind it.

For travel that gets the details right, visit gocalette.com slash podcast, and use offer

code travel26 to get $200 off select collect explorations tours.

The all new 2026 Toyota RAV4 is here, and it builds on everything drivers know and love

about Toyota, with a redesigned look and modern tech that makes life behind the wheel easier

than ever.

The 26 RAV4 comes standard as a hybrid, providing smooth, efficient performance for both city streets

and longer journeys, while the available all-wheel drive keeps you in command when conditions

are unpredictable.

The new RAV4 is designed around the way people actually use their SUV, from daily errands

to weekend adventures, while the GR Sport model, coming soon, both CNET combined 320 horsepower

in a plug-in hybrid drivetrain with a GR tuned suspension for an even more responsive, exciting

drive.

No matter which RAV4 you choose, you'll enjoy the reliability Toyota is known for, coupled

with the inspiring performance that's unique to Toyota.

Shop more and find details at toyota.com.

Before her name appeared in headlines across the country, 30-year-old Micah Miller was

known first to the people closest to her, her friends, family, and members of her solid

rock church community in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.

Micah's family described her as joyous, creative, and energetic, but most notably, she was passionate

about her church, and her greatest desire was seeing people come to Jesus.

And through solid rock church, she eventually found what she believed was loved to.

In 2009, when Micah was only 14 years old, she met 28-year-old pastor and founder of Solid

Rock Church, John Paul Miller.

They claimed to have only been friends at that time, but fast forward to 2015.

When Micah was just 21, and JP was 35, things turned romantic.

However, at this time, both JP and Micah were married to other people, but the affair

turned more serious when they both divorced their spouses to be with each other, and by

2018, Micah and JP were married.

For Micah and JP, religion was not a background element in their lives and relationship.

It shaped how they understood hardship, endurance, and responsibility.

But for Micah, that responsibility also included taking on the role of stepmother to JP's

five children at only 23 years old.

For any 23-year-old, it would be a lot of pressure to go from a marriage with no children

to a divorce to another marriage with five step children.

She also took on an additional role as the senior pastor's wife, something she did not take

lightly.

She led youth groups, led worship, and set a standard for serving her community.

She also knew she had a platform and people looking up to her, and she used it wisely.

In videos and recorded messages that would later circulate publicly, Micah spoke about

scripture, suffering, and the belief that pain could be endured with purpose.

But at times, she also spoke about abuse.

And with those core beliefs in mind, we'll dive a bit deeper inside her marriage to

pastor John Paul Miller.

On the surface, there was no public indications of criminal behavior, no arrests, no charges,

no headlines, nothing that would set alarms to those who knew Micah well.

But according to later federal filings, the private reality of their marriage began to

shift in ways that were not visible to most people around them.

By late 2022, their marriage reportedly was under strain and began to unravel.

By November of 2022, Micah and John Paul Miller's relationship took a turn for the worst.

Federal prosecutors alleged that JP engaged in a pattern of behavior towards Micah that

would later form the basis of a cyber stocking case.

At the time, the couple was still legally married, but Micah had begun taking steps to distance

herself.

Basically, emotionally and financially.

According to court documents, investigators believe this period marked at the beginning

of repeated, unwanted electronic communications directed at Micah.

Contacts that were persistent, intrusive, and increasingly difficult to avoid.

However, none of this was public at the time.

What most people outside of the relationship, especially in the church, saw was a couple

navigating normal marital challenges, not a situation that isolated Micah and made

her feel unsafe.

By January of 2023, Micah and JP were separated and living apart.

But if you've worked with victims of domestic violence, you sadly know that this is the

most dangerous time for women.

The worst thing for abusers is losing control over their victims, which is why 70% of women

who are murdered by their abusers are murdered after they leave.

There's a ledge that during this period, JP continued monitoring Micah's movements

and interfering with her daily life.

Prosecutors also alleged that JP interfered with her finances in banking access, making

it harder for her to live independently, which isn't surprising given the fact that financial

abuse is one of the most common abuse tactics, and unfortunately extremely effective.

Because if a victim doesn't have money or a support system, they have nowhere to go.

At the time, that pattern mostly existed in Micah's own records, but as their separation

continued and JP's behavior started escalating, Micah contacted police multiple times.

She did everything right, reported all of the ways he was trying to scare and intimidate

her, and got everything on record.

She described behavior from her estranged husband that she found frightening and destabilizing.

Officers responded, took reports and documented incidents, but without visible injuries or

a single, clearly chargeable event, the response often stopped there.

What investigators would later emphasize is that many of the behavior's Micah was reporting

fell into a category that is difficult to address through traditional criminal statutes,

particularly at the state level, which in my opinion is one of the biggest failures

of our justice system, and why so many people call stalking murder and slow motion.

By October 8, 2023, Micah and JP officially filed for divorce, and according to Regina Ward

and Attorney representing Micah's family, she kept extensive records.

These records included text messages, videos, journal entries, and documentation of incidents

she believed demonstrated a pattern of course of behavior and abuse.

Ward later described this as a multi-page list, with corroborating evidence attached to

nearly every entry.

At the time, those materials were being gathered for family court, with no intention of a federal

criminal case.

But Micah continued collecting them anyway.

Under South Carolina law, divorces can be legally complex, particularly when claims center

around emotional or psychological abuse rather than physical violence.

Friends and advocates would later say that Micah felt boxed in, trying to meet legal requirements

while also navigating which she believed was ongoing interference in her life.

During this high stress time on February 8, 2024, there was a brief halt in the divorce

proceedings.

Micah was involuntarily hospitalized and placed on a 48-hour hold.

After she was discharged on February 10, hospital staffers told Micah that JP, who she was

actively in the process of getting a divorce from, reportedly picked up her curse and

parkies while she was hospitalized.

When she returned to the Walmart parking lot where she left her car before being placed

on hold, it was gone.

But Micah continued to keep notes of this kind of behavior, and by February 21, 2024,

she reported to police that she believed JP was the one who initiated her involuntary

hospitalization and accused him of taking the car while she was placed on hold.

She also claimed that he had groomed her since she was 14 years old.

Officers then went to get JP's side of the story, and he said that Micah suffers from

episodes on occasion when she would stop taking her medication.

And for Micah, as well as many victims of abuse, her claims took a back seat.

Since on paper Micah and JP were still legally married, her car was considered marital property.

As a result, no charges were filed against JP and he continued to have control over her.

About a month later, on March 11, Micah contacted police again after reporting that a metal blade

had slashed her tire, and that it was the second time it happened that week.

An officer confirmed it to be a tire deflation device that could be purchased online.

But there was no witness who could connect JP or anyone else to the crimes.

In that same report, Micah told police she had noticed strange activity and believed

people were following or watching her.

But once again, police stated that there was not enough evidence to prove those claims.

That same day, after speaking with police, Micah stopped at a gas station before going

to the mechanic to get her tire looked at.

At the gas station, she was approached by the alleged suspect who slashed her tires.

Micah told the suspect whose name is redacted from reports to leave her alone and when

she got her phone out to record him, he sped off.

So once again, Micah feeling terrified and on guard filed another report with police when

she got to the mechanic.

While she was talking with authorities, she kept receiving calls and messages from a

no-color ID.

In the police report, the officer included that Micah told them that she feared for her life.

Additionally, after officers left, a mechanic discovered a GPS tracking device beneath Micah's

vehicle.

Records show that Micah went to the magistrate's office later that day and met with an

officer to pursue a restraining order against JP.

While they were talking out in front of the office, the suspect slowly drove by them, then

sped off.

About two weeks after these stalking and harassment reports, on March 26, her case was finally

moving forward in a civil court, with the hopes of receiving a restraining order against

JP.

But unfortunately, the case was dismissed without prejudice, which means it's not dismissed

forever.

Micah could refile the restraining order again, but for the time she was left without any

protection, despite documenting multiple instances of harassment, stalking, intimidation,

and cyber-socking over a span of months.

And despite doing everything in her power to put a stop to the abuse, the courts failed

her.

By April of 2024, about a month after attempting to obtain a restraining order, Micah continued

moving forward with divorce proceedings and remained living separately from her estranged

husband.

There had been no reported reconciliation during that period.

According to family members and later affidavits, Micah formally served JP with divorce papers

on April 25, 2024.

A step that made her separation official in the eyes of the court, but in the 48 hours

that followed, people close to Micah noticed to change.

Communications from her slowed and then stopped altogether.

Messages went unanswered, halls were not returned.

At first, there was uncertainty about what the silence meant, and whether it meant anything

at all.

However, there was no immediate alarm.

Micah was an adult, she had been living independently, and she was navigating significant personal

and legal challenges.

But as time passed, that uncertainty became harder to ignore.

By late April, concern began to grow as family and friends tried to piece together when they

had last heard from her, where she had said she was going, and what plans she had made,

would initially felt like a delay in communication began to feel like something more serious.

Members would later determine that on April 27, 2024, Micah left the Murnal Beach area.

At the time, however, there was no clear understanding of where she had gone or why.

No one publicly knew her destination.

But one thing was clear, Micah was missing, and no one could reach her.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.

What if comparing car insurance rates was as easy as putting on your favorite podcast?

With Progressive, it is.

Just visit the Progressive website to quote with all the coverages you want.

You'll see Progressive's direct rate, then their tool will provide options from other

companies so you can compare.

All you need to do is choose the rate and coverage you like.

Quote today at Progressive.com to join the over 28 million drivers who trust Progressive.

Progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates.

In rates not available in all states or situations, price is very based on how you buy.

Testing season is right around the corner, and this is when confidence really matters.

When kids take time to review key concepts and strengthen their skills before assessments,

it can make all the difference.

IXL helps reinforce what they're learning right now, so they walk into every test feeling

prepared, capable and confident.

IXL is an award-winning online learning platform that helps kids truly understand

what they're learning, whether they're building math confidence, strengthening reading

and writing skills, or reviewing science concepts.

Designed for students from pre-K through 12th grade, IXL delivers personalized interactive

practice that adapts to your child's level and pace.

It's an easy, effective way to support learning as the school year heads into its final stretch.

Studies show kids who use IXL score higher on tests, proven in all 50 states.

IXL is used in 96 of the top 100 school districts in the US.

Make an impact on your child's learning, get IXL now, and listeners can get an exclusive

20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at IXLLearning.com slash audio.

Visit IXLLearning.com slash audio to get the most effective learning program out there

at the best price.

As concerned for Micah Miller's whereabouts escalated, law enforcement was notified

and a missing person's investigation began.

Officers with the Myrtle Beach Police Department working alongside other agencies started

by attempting to establish Micah's last known movements and location, using a combination

of surveillance footage, transaction records, and phone data.

Investigators began reconstructing her final hours.

That effort quickly established a critical fact.

On April 27, 2024, Micah left her home at 11.38 a.m.

Surveillance video captured her departing away from the coast.

At 12.13 p.m., investigators confirmed Micah stopped at a pawn shop in Myrtle Beach,

where surveillance footage also showed her purchasing a firearm in ammunition.

That transaction, timestamp, and documented became a key marker in the developing timeline.

One records then placed Micah in Robison County, North Carolina at 2.54 p.m.

She then made a 911 call from the area near Lumber River State Park, and asked if her

phone could be located.

Then threatened suicide.

Let's listen to the audio of Micah's call.

Robison County 911, what's the address of your emergency?

Hi, are you able to trace the location of my phone?

It won't be the Lumber River State Park, and that's where I am.

Tell me what's going to happen.

I'm about to kill myself, and I just want my family to know where to find me.

Deputies were discharged to her location shortly afterward to conduct a welfare check.

Data from her phone and vehicle indicated her car was last located near the park, which

is more than an hour from her Myrtle Beach residents, for investigators that terrain presented

immediate challenges upon arrival.

The park covers thousands of acres, much of it remote and difficult to navigate.

For family and friends waiting for news, the uncertainty was agonizing.

As the search continued, officers narrowed their focus based on what information they had

from her cell phone data, and later that same day authorities located Micah's body

in the Lumber River State Park.

Investigators secured the area, documented physical evidence, and began determining what

had happened.

The sheriff's office reported that a person had heard a cry, followed by a gunshot around

4.23 pm.

Micah's cause of death was a single gunshot wound to the head, and her body was found

in the water.

There was no indication of another person being present at the scene.

The Robison County Medical Examiner quickly reached a conclusion, and ruled Micah's death

as suicide.

Officials stated there were no signs of foul play and no evidence suggesting a homicide

at the scene.

From a procedural standpoint, the case appeared resolved, and in most circumstances that

ruling would have marked the end of the investigation.

In the immediate aftermath of events, JP addressed his church congregation the very next

day.

According to reports at the time, he shared the news of Micah's death during the worship

service, telling members that she had passed away and that her death was self-induced.

He also spoke about her struggles with mental health and asked the congregation to pray for

his family.

Let's listen.

I got a call late last night.

My wife has passed away.

It was self-induced, and it was up in North Carolina, and we're going to have a funeral

for her next Sunday here at 3 pm, and so it's all I can do.

I'm just kind of going to the adrenaline right now, so you all pray for me and my kids

and everybody, and she wasn't, you all knew that she wasn't well mentally, and then she

needed medicine that was hard to get through her.

The lack of emotion in his sermon allegedly sparked concern among people in the congregation,

and as investigators dug deeper, Micah's death raised some questions and speculations.

With all of the police reports, recorded complaints, messages, records she compiled for

her attorney, and her attempt at obtaining a restraining order against JP.

It became increasingly clear.

There was more to the story.

In the days following Micah's death, investigators began reviewing information that pointed to

potential criminal conduct, occurring prior to her disappearance.

This included allegations against JP of repeated, unwanted contact, surveillance, and interference

in her daily life.

And on May 6, 2024, the Robison County Sheriff's Office formally requested assistance from

federal authorities.

Shortly thereafter, the FBI became involved.

On this point forward, the investigation focused not on the cause of death, but on what

investigators alleged Micah experienced in the months leading up to it.

As federal agents began their work, the scope of their investigation quickly narrowed to

a single individual, JP Miller.

Agents reviewed communication records, subpoena documents, and analyzed materials Micah had

gathered while preparing for her divorce.

During this time, there were no public arrests, no charges announced, and no court date scheduled.

From the outside, it appeared as though it was an open and shut case.

But as news of Micah's death circulated, and more information came out surrounding

his behavior during the months leading up to her death, public reaction intensified.

Some questioned how a woman who had contacted police multiple times and feared for her

life could disappear and die without further legal consequences.

Others urged caution pointing to the medical examiner's ruling, and the absence of evidence

suggesting homicide.

At the same time, they did confirm that a federal investigation into her death was ongoing,

and that's when the FBI started slowly closing in on JP Miller.

On December 12, Disney Plus invites you to go behind the scenes with Taylor Swift in an

exclusive six-episode docu-series.

I wanted to give something to the fans that they didn't expect.

The only thing left is to close the book.

The end of an era.

And don't miss Taylor Swift, the era's tour, the final show featuring for the first time

at Torture Poets to Farmat.

On December 12, only on Disney Plus.

Are you stuck staring at your W2?

Our tax refund worry is holding you back.

You probably have FOMO.

The fear of messing up.

The fix?

Using turbo-tax on into a credit karma, they find every credit and deduction to help you

get every refund dollar you deserve, or your money back.

It's time to overcome your fear of messing up, and get your taxes done right.

Start filing today in the Credit Karma Act.

High listeners, it's Vanessa Richardson.

I wanted to take a brief moment to tell you about another show from Crime House that I

know you'll love.

America's most infamous crimes, hosted by Katie Ring.

Each week, Katie takes on a notorious crime, whether unfolding now or etched into American

history, revealing not just what happened, but how it forever changed our society.

Serial killers who terrorized cities, unsolved mysteries that keep detectives up at night,

and investigations that changed the way we think about justice.

Each case unfolds across multiple episodes, released every Tuesday through Thursday,

from the first sign that something was wrong to the moment the truth came out, or didn't.

These are the stories behind the headlines.

Coming to and follow America's most infamous crimes, Tuesday through Thursday, on Apple

podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

As the allegations against John Paul Miller became public knowledge, he was released from

his duties as Senior Pastor at the Solid Rock Church, nearly one month after Mike's death.

He maintained he had nothing to do with her suicide, and even when as far as saying that

he suspected she was going to do this for years now.

As Mike as family spoke out, outrage and speculation online and on social media ran wild.

Mike and Miller sister Sierra Frances and other family members questioned the official

ruling of suicide.

Despite the Robison County Sheriff's Office ruling the death of suicide by a self-inflicted

gunshot wound, the family believes the scene was state.

And that she was the victim of abuse and course of control.

In an affidavit, Sierra stated that Micah had previously told her quote,

If I end up with a bullet in my head, it was not by me, it was JP.

They also found it implausible that Micah's body was found in a location separate from

her personal belongings, including her purse and her phone, which were found on a different

trail.

People online also dissected the odd 911 call, and internet sleuths pointed to another

mysterious death that was adjacent to JP.

Allegedly, he had an affair with a woman named Susie Skinner while he was married to Micah.

In 2021, Susie's husband, Chris Skinner, also died under mysterious circumstances.

He was wheelchair-bound and according to reports, he died after falling into the pool.

According to this speculation was the fact that JP and Susie tied the knot a little over

a year after Micah's death.

But despite all of the odd circumstances surrounding this case, authorities need solid evidence

for any prosecution.

Months passed without any updates, but as we know, federal investigations often unfold slowly,

especially when prosecutors are deciding whether or not evidence meets the threshold for

criminal charges.

However, JP was arrested in November of 2024 on an unrelated assault and battery charge

after an altercation with a justice for Micah protestor outside the church.

JP allegedly pointed his phone in her face and tapped the rim of her hat.

He was taken into custody and released to the next day on a $776 bond.

But by late 2024, the federal investigation into Micah's death had reached a pivotal

point.

This had been collected, witnesses had been interviewed, and records had been reviewed.

The only question left was whether federal prosecutors believe the case warranted formal

charges, or a long time there was no public answer, until suddenly there was.

In October of 2025, JP admitted to authorities that he had hired a private investigator to

keep an eye on Micah to make sure that she wouldn't buy a gun or harm herself.

But the reality of that statement is allegedly false.

JP is accused of hiring the private investigator to cyber stalk her after she was allegedly

unfaithful in their marriage.

So by December of 2025, investigators felt they had enough to proceed.

A federal grand jury released a two-count indictment against JP Miller,

formally charging him with cyber stalking and making false statements to federal investigators.

According to the indictment, prosecutors alleged that from November of 2022,

through April of 2024, JP engaged in a sustained pattern of behavior directed at Micah.

His alleged conduct also included threatening to use intimate images to intimidate

or harass and posting nude photos of Micah online without her consent.

Prosecutors described these actions as part of a broader pattern, repeated conduct intended

to have control over someone.

According to the indictment, authorities alleged he made false statements to investigators

by lying about his involvement in damaging the tires on Micah's car.

Federal prosecutors argued these alleged false statements affected the course of the investigation.

And in federal court, lying to investigators is treated as a separate crime,

regardless of whether the underlying conduct can be proven.

Cyber stalking cases do not automatically fall under federal jurisdiction.

What brings them there are specific factors, including the use of electronic communications,

interstate activity, and conduct that crosses state lines.

In this case, prosecutors alleged those thresholds were met,

and on January 12, 2026, JP Miller appeared in federal court,

in Florence, South Carolina, for his arrangement. Outside of the court house,

dozens of people gathered, some carried signs, other stood silently.

Many said they were there to get justice for Micah.

Inside the courtroom, the proceeding itself was brief.

He was formally advised on the charges against him, and he entered a plea of not guilty.

He was also granted a continuance, meaning his next court date has been postponed to allow

more time before proceedings resume. If convicted, JP faces up to five years

in federal prison for cyber stalking, up to two additional years for making false statements,

and potential fines totaling tens of thousands of dollars.

As of this recording, JP Miller remains out of jail on a hundred thousand dollar bond,

and his next court date is scheduled for March 2026.

This case has drawn national attention not only because of who is charged,

but because of what the charges describe. Cyber stalking, surveillance, mental and emotional

abuse, and control exercised without physical violence. Prosecutors have emphasized that abuse

does not always leave visible marks, and that federal law recognizes patterns of conduct,

not just single acts. The investigation that began quietly,

after many believe the case was over, is now firmly within the justice system.

What remains are unanswered questions, and a legal process still unfolding.

For now, the case of Micah Miller stands at that threshold. We'll continue to follow the case

as it moves through the federal system and bring you updates as they happen.

If you or someone you know is experiencing abuse, you can call the National Domestic Violence

hotline at 1-800-799-7233.

What did you think of tonight's case? Drop your thoughts and theories in the comments.

See you next time. If you haven't already, make sure to follow us wherever you get your podcasts

and subscribe to our YouTube channel at NightwatchPod. Your support means everything.

Thanks for listening to today's episode. Not sure what to listen to next? Check out America's

most infamous crimes hosted by Katie Ring. From serial killers to unsolved mysteries and

game-changing investigations, each week Katie takes on a notorious criminal case in American history.

Listen to and follow America's most infamous crimes now wherever you listen to podcasts.