0:00
Tyler Reddick here from 2311 Racing.
0:02
Another checkered flag for the books.
0:04
Time to celebrate with Jamba.
0:06
Jump in at JambaCasino.com.
0:09
No purchase necessary, BTW Group.
0:11
Boy, we're prohibited by law.
0:12
CCNC is 21 plus sponsored by JambaCasino.
0:17
Proves, just because something on the job runs out
0:19
doesn't mean you have to.
0:21
Order it on the Lowes app.
0:22
My Lowes Pro rewards members get free
0:24
same-day delivery on eligible orders over $25.
0:27
Get the fasteners, hardware, or tools you need
0:30
to keep the job moving.
0:31
Order by 2 p.m. and get eligible in stock items delivered
0:34
right to your job site by 8 p.m.
0:38
Loyalty programs subject to terms and conditions.
0:40
Subject to availability restrictions
0:42
in terms of lows.com slash shipping terms.
0:45
History says the mystery was solved.
0:47
History is very confident about that.
0:51
Welcome to Unsolved-ish, a strange history podcast
0:55
where we examine crimes, disasters,
0:58
and scientific weirdness that were wrapped up
1:01
with the historical equivalent of met,
1:04
probably vanished ships, Victorian murderers,
1:08
glowing lights, scientists keep siding.
1:11
If the explanation feels rushed, overly tidy
1:14
or suspiciously convenient,
1:16
we're already recording an episode about it.
1:19
No shouting, no wild theories.
1:22
Just a calm voice asking, are we sure about this?
1:26
Unsolved-ish, a brand new podcast
1:29
brought to you by Strange History Studios
1:32
because history loves closure,
1:33
even when it didn't earn it.
1:35
Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
1:38
Unsolved-ish, a strange history podcast.
1:41
Hello dear listeners and welcome back to Unsolved-ish,
1:44
which is brought to you by the Strange History Podcast Studios.
1:47
Tonight we're going to Victorian London,
1:49
a city that believed deeply in order progress
1:52
and the comforting idea that if something was truly dangerous,
1:56
someone official would surely handle it, preferably quietly,
2:00
preferably without disturbing polite society.
2:04
Between 1887 and 1889, pieces of human bodies
2:09
began surfacing in and around the river Thames,
2:12
not full bodies, not recognizable victims, just torsos,
2:17
carefully dismembered, wrapped, deposited
2:21
where they would eventually be found,
2:23
but not immediately identified.
2:25
This series of discoveries would become known
2:28
as the Thames Torso murders.
2:31
And while Victorian authorities insisted
2:33
these were isolated incidents,
2:36
history has never quite agreed,
2:38
because once you start finding bodies
2:40
without heads, hands, or feet,
2:43
coincidence stops being convincing.
2:46
The first discovery came in September of 1887
2:50
when a parcel was pulled from the Thames near Reynum.
2:53
Inside was a female torso, missing limbs and head.
2:57
At first, police treated it as a single tragic anomaly.
3:02
Victorian London was large, after all, people disappeared.
3:06
Accidents happened, crimes happened.
3:09
But then another torso surfaced, and then another,
3:12
found in different locations at different times,
3:15
but with unsettling similarities,
3:18
the bodies were cleanly dismembered,
3:20
suggesting anatomical knowledge,
3:22
or at least confidence with tools.
3:25
The cuts weren't frantic, they were purposeful.
3:28
This wasn't panic, this was procedure.
3:31
And crucially, removing heads, hands, and feet
3:34
made identification nearly impossible.
3:37
Something investigators absolutely noticed,
3:39
even if they didn't fully acknowledge what it implied.
3:43
Victorian policing was still finding its footing.
3:46
Forensics, as we understand it, barely existed.
3:50
There was no fingerprint database, no blood typing, no DNA.
3:54
Investigators relied on physical description, clothing,
3:58
and witnesses, none of which were particularly helpful
4:02
when the identifying parts of the body were gone.
4:05
Rather than treat the cases as connected,
4:08
authorities repeatedly declared them unrelated,
4:11
different victims, different circumstances,
4:14
different explanations.
4:17
This wasn't a serial crime they insisted, it was coincidence.
4:21
A series of unfortunate, disconnected events
4:24
that just happened to involve torso's in the same river,
4:28
which feels like a stretch.
4:31
What complicates things further is the timing.
4:35
These murders occurred during the same period,
4:38
London was gripped by another unresolved horror, Jack the Ripper.
4:44
Public fear was already high.
4:46
The press was volatile.
4:48
And the last thing authorities wanted
4:50
was another killer narrative taking hold,
4:53
especially one that suggested a methodical,
4:56
unidentified murderer operating quietly over years.
5:01
So the torso cases were minimized, downplayed, fragmented,
5:06
both literally and administratively.
5:09
One particularly infamous discovery,
5:12
known as the Whitehall Mystery,
5:14
involved a torso found beneath the construction site
5:17
of the new Scotland Yard Building itself.
5:20
If that doesn't feel symbolic, nothing does.
5:23
A body incomplete and unidentified
5:26
found under the future home of British law enforcement
5:29
and still no arrest.
5:32
Doctors debated causes of death.
5:34
Some suggested abortion-related deaths,
5:37
others speculated medical experimentation
5:40
or concealment of accidental killings.
5:43
Each explanation allowed the case to stay small,
5:47
personal, isolated, nothing systemic, nothing serial.
5:52
And that's the pattern you start to notice.
5:54
Every explanation shrank the story.
5:57
No unified investigation, no task force,
6:00
no acknowledgement that a single person or group
6:04
might be responsible.
6:06
For most of the Thames torso murders,
6:08
the victims were never identified,
6:10
and that wasn't an accident of circumstance
6:13
so much as a consequence of how the bodies
6:15
were deliberately treated.
6:17
Heads, hands, and feet were removed.
6:20
The very features Victorian investigators relied on
6:23
to recognize someone.
6:24
With no fingerprints, no dental records,
6:27
and no modern forensic tools,
6:30
identification became almost impossible.
6:33
As a result, the majority of the victims remain nameless,
6:37
reduced to fragments in official reports,
6:40
and quickly filed away as isolated tragedies
6:43
rather than parts of a larger pattern.
6:46
There is, however, one partial exception
6:49
that Victorian authorities held onto as proof
6:52
that the situation was under control.
6:55
In 1889, body parts recovered from several locations
6:59
along the River Thames were believed to belong
7:03
Investigators eventually linked these remains
7:06
to a missing woman named Elizabeth Jackson.
7:10
The identification was made through circumstantial evidence,
7:14
fragments of clothing that matched what she was known to wear,
7:17
physical characteristics consistent with recent pregnancy,
7:21
and testimony from people who had seen her
7:23
shortly before she disappeared.
7:25
By modern standards, this would be considered
7:28
far from conclusive, but at the time it was deemed sufficient.
7:32
What's most telling is what happened next.
7:35
Elizabeth Jackson's name went into the record,
7:38
but no suspect was ever identified, questioned, or charged.
7:43
Her death, like the others, was acknowledged
7:46
without being explained.
7:48
The remaining torso cases were never revisited as a group,
7:52
never reclassified as potentially connected,
7:55
and never fully investigated beyond their individual discoveries.
7:59
By treating each body as a separate incident
8:02
and leaving most victims unidentified,
8:05
authorities avoided confronting the possibility
8:07
of a serial offender operating in Victorian London.
8:11
That's why the identification of Elizabeth Jackson
8:14
doesn't feel like a breakthrough.
8:16
It feels like a stopping point.
8:18
One name allowed one file to be closed,
8:21
even though it didn't answer who killed her or why.
8:25
And for the rest of the victims, anonymity made closure
8:29
No names meant no families pushing for answers,
8:32
no missing persons connections to chase,
8:35
and no pressure to keep digging.
8:37
In the end, the Thames torso murders
8:39
weren't solved so much as quietly compartmentalized.
8:43
Their most important questions left floating unresolved,
8:47
just like the bodies themselves.
8:49
Eventually, the discoveries stopped,
8:52
or at least they stopped being connected.
8:56
Files were closed, in quests ended with vague conclusions,
9:01
and Victorian London moved on,
9:03
satisfied that no official panic had been justified.
9:07
But here's the thing, crimes don't become unrelated
9:10
just because we say they are,
9:12
and stopping an investigation isn't the same
9:15
as stopping a killer.
9:16
The Thames torso murders weren't solved.
9:19
They were administratively dismantled,
9:21
broken into smaller, less alarming pieces
9:24
until no one was responsible for the whole.
9:27
Could these murders be connected
9:29
to the Jack the Ripper murders?
9:31
This question has been asked for more than a century,
9:34
and the honest answer is,
9:36
it's possible, but unprovable,
9:38
and Victorian authorities worked very hard
9:41
to keep the two separate.
9:42
The Thames torso murders and Jack the Ripper
9:45
overlapped in time, place, and public fear
9:49
in a way that makes comparison almost unavoidable.
9:52
Several torso discoveries occurred in the late 1880s,
9:56
right as London was panicking over a killer targeting women.
10:00
Bodies were appearing in public spaces,
10:03
victims were being dismembered,
10:06
and crucially, the crime suggested someone
10:08
with confidence, time, and a disturbing level of control.
10:13
That said, the methods are very different,
10:15
and that's where most modern historians hesitate.
10:19
Jack the Ripper's known victims were killed quickly
10:21
and left where they died,
10:23
with mutilation occurring at the scene.
10:26
The Thames torso victims, by contrast,
10:29
were dismembered elsewhere,
10:31
and then transported, wrapped, and carefully deposited,
10:35
often in or near the river Thames.
10:38
That kind of post-mortem handling suggests planning
10:41
and concealment rather than impulsive violence.
10:45
In other words, one set of crimes is about display,
10:48
the other about removal.
10:50
However, Victorian policing creates a major complication,
10:55
investigators at the time were overwhelmed,
10:57
under-equipped, and extremely sensitive to public panic.
11:02
Linking the torso murders to Jack the Ripper
11:04
would have meant admitting there might be more
11:06
than one serial killer, or worse,
11:09
that a single killer was escalating
11:11
or experimenting with different methods.
11:14
That possibility was deeply uncomfortable,
11:16
especially while the Ripper investigation itself was failing.
11:20
So officials repeatedly insisted
11:22
that the torso cases were unrelated,
11:25
not just to Jack the Ripper, but to each other.
11:29
Some historians have suggested a middle ground,
11:32
not that Jack the Ripper and the torso killer
11:34
were the same person,
11:36
but that they may have shared
11:37
a cultural and criminal environment.
11:40
Victorian London was a place
11:41
where violence against marginalized women,
11:44
especially the poor, often went under-investigated.
11:48
Dismembriment wasn't unheard of
11:50
in cases involving concealment,
11:52
abortion-related deaths, or domestic crimes.
11:56
The similarities may reflect opportunity
11:59
and neglect more than a single hand at work.
12:02
What keeps the theory alive isn't strong evidence.
12:07
No one was ever caught for the torso murders.
12:11
No definitive Ripper suspect was ever proven.
12:14
The investigations were fragmented, reactive,
12:17
and shaped as much by reputation management
12:19
as by fact-finding.
12:21
In that kind of environment,
12:22
connections don't just go undiscovered.
12:25
They go un-pursued.
12:26
So could the Tim's torso murders
12:28
be linked to Jack the Ripper, possibly?
12:31
Could they also represent a different offender
12:34
whose crimes were minimized
12:36
to avoid further panic, equally possible?
12:39
What's clear is that Victorian London
12:41
chose not to look too closely,
12:43
and once that decision was made,
12:45
any chance of certainty vanished with it.
12:49
This episode is brought to you by Victorian conclusions,
12:52
because if you separate the evidence enough,
12:54
eventually, it stops asking questions.
12:57
Victorian conclusions, individually tragic,
13:02
Bubble Wallace here from 2311 Racing.
13:06
You know it's slower than a pace car?
13:09
Waiting at the car wash.
13:10
That's when I fire up Jumbak Casino.
13:13
It turns those slow minutes into fast fun.
13:16
With new games every week, you'll never get bored.
13:19
Next time you're stuck in the slow lane,
13:20
speed up with Jumbak.
13:21
Play now at chumbakacino.com.
13:25
Sponsored by Jumbakacino, no purchase necessary,
13:27
VGW GroupFord, where prohibited by law,
13:29
21 plus terms and conditions apply.
13:32
If you like True Crime, you'll love the Miracle Files podcast.
13:36
We share real stories with the suspense of True Crime,
13:39
but we'll leave you with a sense of light and hope.
13:42
Like the college wrestler who fought grizzly,
13:44
the woman who was dead for nearly an hour,
13:47
or the child lost in a dark mind for days.
13:50
These are the kind of stories that remind us.
13:54
Subscribe to the Miracle Files, wherever you get your podcasts,
13:58
and join us on this thrilling journey of faith and miracles.
14:02
Each week, the world of archaeology, geology,
14:05
and science in general makes a number
14:07
of startling discoveries about our past
14:10
that isn't necessarily reported to the general public.
14:14
These are cultures that we don't know about,
14:16
science that we haven't discovered,
14:18
and other archaeological phenomenon that is unusual,
14:23
and just too much to report on.
14:24
Hey, this is Cliff, your host of Earth Ancients,
14:26
and each Saturday, we present a new topic
14:31
that defies logic that isn't covered in the news
14:34
because it's just too amazing,
14:37
and brings us closer to questions about our past.
14:42
Join me as we explore Earth's ancient past
14:45
with writers, scientists, and research investigators.
14:49
That's Earth Ancients, voted the number one
14:52
ancient history podcast in the country.
14:57
What makes this case linger isn't just the brutality.
15:01
It's the confidence, the calm certainty
15:04
with which authorities insisted there was nothing to see here,
15:07
even as body parts continued to appear in public spaces.
15:11
The refusal to connect dots because connecting them
15:14
would require admitting failure.
15:16
And perhaps most unsettling of all is this.
15:20
Whoever committed these crimes was never caught,
15:22
never named, and never stopped by the system
15:25
meant to do exactly that.
15:28
The Thames Torso murders exist in a strange historical limbo,
15:32
not infamous enough to haunt like Jack the Ripper,
15:35
not obscure enough to disappear entirely,
15:38
just quietly unresolved,
15:40
floating somewhere between denial and neglect.
15:44
Victorian London liked its mysteries neatly contained.
15:47
This one refused, and so it wasn't solved.
15:50
It wasn't disproven.
15:52
It was simply unsolved-ish.
15:55
This has been Unsolved-ish, a strange history podcast.
15:59
If you enjoyed this, please like and subscribe,
16:02
and check out our other podcast, The Strange History Podcast,
16:05
found wherever you like to listen to podcasts.
16:10
Tala Redic here from 2311 Racing.
16:19
The rush of racing?
16:21
Nothing beats it, but Chumba Casino comes close.
16:24
Chumba's got fast spins, fun games, daily bonuses,
16:28
and all the action you can handle.
16:33
Ready to hit the throttle?
16:34
Get in the driver's seat and head to chumbacasino.com.
16:39
Sponsored by Chumba Casino.
16:40
No purchase necessary, VGW Group Voidware prohibited by law,
16:43
21 plus turns and conditions apply.
16:45
Tala Redic here from 2311 Racing.
16:49
Yeah, it's even better with Chumba by my side.
16:52
Race to chumbacasino.com.
16:55
No purchase necessary, VGW Group Voidware prohibited by law,
16:58
CTNC's, 21 plus sponsored by Chumba Casino.