When Newspapers Fooled the World: Giants, Fairies, and the Greatest Hoaxes in History

Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance,

but now we're customizing this ad for your morning commute to wake you up.

Which could help your driving?

Science says that stimulating the brain increases alertness.

So here's a pop quiz.

How many months have 28 days?

What gets wetter as it dries?

What is keys but can't open locks?

If you don't want to hear the answers,

turn off this Liberty Mutual ad now.

12 Months, a towel, piano.

Enjoy being fully alert.

Liberty, Liberty, Liberty, Liberty.

Bubble Wallace here from 2311 Racing.

You know what's slower than a pace car?

Waiting at the car wash.

That's when I fire up Chamba Casino.

It turns those slow minutes into fast fun.

With new games every week, you'll never get bored.

Next time you're stuck in the slow lane, speed up with Chamba.

Play now at chambacasino.com.

Let's Chamba.

Sponsored by Chamba Casino.

No purchase necessary.

VGW Group Void we're prohibited by law.

21 plus terms and conditions apply.

History says the mystery was solved.

History is very confident about that.

Welcome to Unsolved-ish, a strange history podcast

where we examine crimes, disasters,

and scientific weirdness that were wrapped up

with the historical equivalent of met,

probably vanished ships, Victorian murderers,

glowing lights, scientists keep siding.

If the explanation feels rushed, overly tidy,

or suspiciously convenient,

we're already recording an episode about it.

No shouting, no wild theories.

Just a calm voice asking,

are we sure about this?

Unsolved-ish, a brand new podcast brought to you

by Strange History Studios.

Because history loves closure,

even when it didn't earn it.

Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

Unsolved-ish, a strange history podcast.

Hello, dear listeners.

Long before the internet,

long before social media,

and long before the phrase fake news,

became part of everyday conversation,

newspapers were the fastest way information

traveled across the world.

In the 19th and early 20th centuries,

people depended on newspapers not only

for politics and local events,

but also for scientific discoveries,

medical breakthroughs,

and strange wonders reported from distant places.

For many readers,

the printed word carried an almost sacred authority.

If something appeared in the newspaper,

it must surely be true.

That assumption created the perfect environment

for some of the strangest hoaxes in history.

During this period,

newspapers competed fiercely for attention,

and sensational stories could dramatically increase circulation.

Readers loved astonishing discoveries,

mysterious creatures,

and scientific breakthroughs

that promised to change humanity's understanding of the world.

Sometimes those stories were real,

and sometimes they were completely invented.

One of the most famous examples arrived in 1869,

when workers digging a well on a farm in upstate New York,

supposedly uncovered something extraordinary.

Buried in the earth was what appeared to be

the petrified body of a giant human being

nearly 10 feet tall.

The discovery spread quickly

through newspapers across the country.

Crowds began traveling to see the mysterious figure,

paying admission to stand before what many believed

was proof that ancient giants once roamed the earth.

The strange artifact became known as the Cardiff Giant,

and for a time thousands of people were convinced

it was a genuine prehistoric relic.

Ministers preached sermons about biblical giants.

Scientists debated its significance,

visitors stared in amazement at the massive stone figure

lying in its display tent.

In reality, the giant had been carefully carved from gypsum,

and secretly buried by a businessman named George Hall,

who wanted to embarrass religious fundamentalists,

who believed ancient giants described in the Bible

were literal historical beings.

Hall never expected the hoax to become so wildly successful.

Within weeks, the giant had become a national attraction.

And even the famous showman P.T. Barnum tried to buy it

so he could display it in his museum.

Eventually, investigators revealed the truth,

but by that time, the Cardiff Giant had already become

one of the most famous hoaxes in American history.

If the Cardiff Giant demonstrated how easily people

could be fooled by archaeology,

the next great hoax revealed how easily photography

could deceive the public.

In 1917, two young girls in England produced photographs

that appeared to show tiny winged fairies dancing

in the garden behind their house.

The pictures were charming, whimsical,

and strangely convincing.

Newspapers published them,

and soon the images spread across the world

as possible evidence that fairies might actually exist.

The photographs became known as the Cottingley fairies,

and the story attracted serious attention

from people who believed the supernatural might be real.

Among the believers was Arthur Conan Doyle,

the famous writer who had spent years researching spiritualism.

Doyle publicly defended the photographs,

convinced they showed genuine magical creatures.

For decades, the images remained controversial.

Only many years later, did the girls admit

that the fairies had simply been paper cutouts

borrowed from a children's book

and held in place with hat pins.

While the fairy photographs fooled the public,

another hoax managed to fool scientists themselves.

In 1912, a fossil discovered in England appeared

to represent the long-sought missing link

between humans and apes.

The skull looked human,

but the jaw resembled that of an ape.

The fossil quickly became famous

and was named Pilt Down Man.

For decades, it was celebrated

as one of the most important discoveries

in human evolution.

Scientists built theories around it,

museums displayed it,

and textbooks described it as evidence

of humanity's ancient past.

Then, 40 years later,

researchers re-examined the fossil

using improved scientific techniques

and discovered something embarrassing.

Pilt Down Man was a fraud.

The skull belonged to a medieval human.

The jaw came from an orangutan.

Both pieces had been artificially stained

and filed to make them appear ancient.

Someone had carefully combined the bones

to create a convincing

but entirely fake evolutionary fossil.

Even today, historians still debate

who created the hoax.

Not all newspaper wonders involved archaeology

or photography.

Some focused on supposed medical miracles.

During the Victorian era,

newspapers sometimes reported stories

about individuals who claimed to survive

without eating.

One of the most famous cases involved

a Welsh girl named Sarah Jacob,

whose family claimed she had lived

for months without consuming food.

Visitors traveled long distances

to see the girl, believing they were

witnessing a supernatural phenomenon.

Some thought she was blessed by divine forces,

while others believed her body

had somehow transcended normal biological needs.

To resolve the mystery,

local authorities arranged for medical supervision.

A team of nurses and doctors

was assigned to observe Sarah continuously

to determine whether she was truly living

without nourishment.

Their goal was straightforward.

Watch her around the clock

to ensure no food or water could secretly be given.

This kind of controlled observation

was one of the earliest attempts

at what we would now call

a scientific verification

of extraordinary claims.

At first, the nurses noticed something unusual.

Sarah appeared extremely weak and thin,

far more fragile than someone

who had supposedly been living normally

without food.

Yet her parents insisted

she had not eaten in many months.

Once the observation began,

the nurses carefully monitored every interaction.

Family members were not allowed

to feed her secretly.

No food or water was permitted

to enter the room without supervision.

Within a few days,

the truth began revealing itself.

Sarah's condition deteriorated rapidly.

She became increasingly weak,

dehydrated,

and unresponsive.

The nurses realized

that if the girl truly had not been eating

before the observation,

she should already have been dead.

The only explanation was

that she had been secretly fed by her parents

while visitors believed she was fasting.

Without that hidden support,

her body quickly began failing.

After several days

under medical observation,

Sarah died from starvation.

The tragedy shocked the public

and immediately exposed the truth

behind the supposed miracle.

Investigators concluded

that Sarah had been secretly fed

during the months

when visitors were arriving

and newspapers were reporting the story.

When the controlled observation

prevented her parents

from continuing that deception,

the girl's body could no longer survive.

The case quickly turned

from curiosity to criminal investigation.

Sarah's parents were charged

with manslaughter

because their deception

had contributed directly

to the conditions that led to her death.

The trial drew enormous public attention,

and the story became one

of the most notorious medical

hoaxes of the Victorian era.

In the end,

scientists did not prove

the hoax through complex technology

or laboratory experiments.

The truth emerged

through a simple principle

that remains central to science today,

controlled observation.

When an extraordinary claim is made,

the only way to test it

is to remove all possible hidden

explanations

and observe what happens.

In Sarah Jacobs' case,

the moment the conditions

of the experiment changed,

the supposed miracle vanished.

The tragic outcome revealed

something important

about both science and human belief.

People are often willing

to believe astonishing claims,

especially when those claims

promise mystery,

miracle,

or supernatural possibility.

Science, however,

requires something different.

It requires proof.

Looking back at these stories today,

they may seem amusing

or even absurd,

yet they reveal something important

about the history of information.

Long before digital media

made misinformation a global problem,

people were already navigating a world

where truth and fiction

could become tangled

in the pages of the daily press.

Human curiosity has always been powerful.

People want to believe

that giants once walked the earth

that magical creatures

might hide in the forest,

that ancient fossils

might reveal humanity's origins,

or that the human body

might possess miraculous abilities.

And sometimes,

a good story is all it takes

to make those possibilities feel real.

Now, a brief word from our sponsor.

This episode is brought to you

by early sensational newspapers.

If your circulation numbers are falling,

simply publish a story

about giant fossilized humans,

dancing fairies,

or miraculous people who never eat.

Early sensational newspapers,

because nothing sells papers

quite like an unbelievable discovery

that turns out not to exist.

Dear listeners,

the strange hoaxes of early newspapers

remind us that misinformation

did not begin with the internet.

For centuries,

people have been captivated

by extraordinary claims

that promise to reveal hidden wonders

about the world.

While science and journalism

have become far more rigorous over time,

the human fascination

with astonishing stories

remains exactly the same.

After all,

sometimes the strangest history

is not what actually happened.

Sometimes,

it is what people believed happened.

Teleredic here from 2311 Racing.

Game night's fun

until someone spends five minutes

lining up one shot.

Chalk,

breathe,

re-chalk,

still aiming.

While they figure it out,

I fire up Chamba Casino.

I can spin anywhere,

anytime,

and there's always a new

social casino game every week.

Spins happen way faster than that shot.

Play now at chambacasino.com.

Let's Chamba.

Sponsored by Chamba Casino,

no purchase necessary.

VGW Group,

voidware prohibited by law,

21 plus terms and conditions

apply.

Teleredic here from 2311 Racing.

Victory Lane?

Yeah,

it's even better with Chamba by my side.

Race to chambacasino.com.

Let's Chamba.

No purchase necessary.

VGW Group,

voidware prohibited by law.

CTNCs,

21 plus.

Sponsored by Chamba Casino.

Teleredic here from 2311 Racing.

Another checkered flag for the books.

Time to celebrate with Chamba.

Jump in at chambacasino.com.

Let's Chamba.

No purchase necessary.

VGW Group,

voidware prohibited by law.

CTNCs,

21 plus.

Sponsored by Chamba Casino.

Hello, it is Ryan,

and we could all use an extra bright spot in our day, couldn't we?

Just to make up for things like sitting in traffic,

doing the dishes,

counting your steps,

you know,

all the mundane stuff.

That is why I'm such a big fan of Chamba Casino.

Chamba Casino has all your favorite social casino style games

that you can play for free anytime, anywhere with daily bonuses.

So sign up now at chambacasino.com.

That's chambacasino.com.