Comp Plan Mistakes That Sabotage Your Sales Team (Ask Jeb)

How can one comp plan mistake sabotage your sales team before they even start? 

That’s the challenge facing Adam and Laura from the Rossen Law Firm in Florida. After attending one of our Dallas workshops, they made the bold decision to transition to a non-attorney sales team. Six weeks later, they’re all in on the strategy but hitting a wall on one critical issue: compensation structure.

The problem? Like most law firms making this transition, they’re stuck in the traditional legal mindset when it comes to paying salespeople. They can’t pay direct commissions because of fee-splitting regulations, but they’re struggling to create a compensation plan that motivates high performance.

If you’re nodding your head right now, you’re not alone. This is the No. 1 stumbling block I see when law firms try to build professional sales teams, and it’s costing them their best talent before they even get started.

The Legal Industry’s Compensation Conundrum

Most law firms approach sales compensation like they’re hiring another paralegal instead of recognizing they’re building a revenue-generating machine.

The traditional legal industry operates on billable hours, retainers, and partnership tracks. But sales? Sales is about results, motivation, and creating an environment where top performers want to stay and mediocre performers either level up or leave.

When you try to force a square peg (sales compensation) into a round hole (traditional legal compensation), you get exactly what Adam and Laura discovered: confusion, frustration, and the risk of incentivizing the wrong behaviors.

Why Fee-Splitting Regulations Actually Work in Your Favor

Before you start cursing the legal profession’s restrictions on fee-splitting, let me share something that might surprise you: This limitation can force you to build a better compensation structure than most sales organizations.

Here’s why: Instead of lazy commission-based thinking, you’re forced to get creative with performance bonuses tied to specific outcomes. This means you can build a compensation plan that rewards the behaviors you actually want, not just the easy stuff.

The key is shifting from a commission mindset to a performance bonus mindset. This isn’t just semantic; it’s a fundamental change in how you think about motivating your sales team. This approach requires strong leadership fundamentals, which is why understanding how to create a sales accountability culture becomes critical to your success.

The Three-Layer Compensation Framework That Actually Works

When I work with law firms on this challenge, I recommend a three-layer approach that satisfies legal requirements while creating real motivation:

Layer 1: Competitive Base Salary

This is your foundation. Pay a competitive salary that attracts superstar talent. Why? Because when you pay superstar wages, you can hold people accountable for superstar performance without them saying “you’re not incentivizing me for that.”

If most of your comp is salary, you can explain expectations clearly and apply leadership, motivation, and inspiration to get people to do the hard things without getting paid extra for everything.

Layer 2: Individual Performance Bonuses (Monthly)

Focus on activity-based goals that drive results:

• Follow-up completion rates
• Number of qualified calls taken
• Conversion rates from initial contact to consultation
• Client onboarding task completion

These should be measured monthly because salespeople need tighter timelines to stay motivated. The fundamentals of effective follow-up and systematic prospecting become crucial here. This is where mastering fanatical prospecting principles makes the difference between good and great performance.

Layer 3: Team and Firm-Level Bonuses (Quarterly/Annual)

This is where you create real ownership mentality:

• Quarterly team goals: Total new clients signed above baseline
• Annual firm goals: Overall revenue growth and profitability targets

Everyone participates in firm-level success, making your sales team feel like partners in growth, not just employees grinding for a paycheck.

The Scenario Planning You Can’t Skip

Here’s where most law firms mess up: They create a compensation plan without thinking through the unintended consequences. Since you’re lawyers, you’re better equipped than most industries to do this right.

Sit down and scenario plan every possible worst-case behavior:

• What if they rush through calls to hit quantity goals?
• What if they only focus on easy cases and ignore complex ones?
• What if they oversell and create client satisfaction issues?
• What if they start competing against one another instead of collaborating?

For each scenario, ask: “Are we willing to accept this risk?” If not, adjust the plan. If yes, commit to coaching against those behaviors through leadership, not just compensation design.

The Power of Non-Monetary Incentives

Don’t underestimate the power of recognition, trophies, and status. Some of your best performers will work harder for public recognition than for an extra $500 bonus.

Consider creating:

• Monthly recognition programs
• Quarterly awards ceremonies
• Annual top performer retreats
• Public acknowledgment in firm communications

You’d be amazed how people will work for a trophy or recognition when combined with fair monetary compensation.

How to Implement Without Paralysis

The biggest mistake I see law firms make is overthinking this to the point of paralysis. You’ll never solve for every scenario upfront, and that’s okay.

Here’s your action plan:

1. Start with a solid base salary that attracts quality talent
2. Add simple, measurable monthly bonuses tied to key activities
3. Layer in team and firm bonuses for broader ownership
4. Plan for quarterly reviews to adjust based on what you learn
5. Watch for unintended behaviors and coach through them

Remember: You can’t legislate perfect behavior through compensation alone. The best compensation plans create motivation, while good leadership creates the culture that sustains high performance.

Building Your Sales Team the Right Way

This compensation challenge is really about something bigger: building a professional sales culture within a legal framework. When you get this right, you’re building a revenue engine that respects your profession’s ethics while driving sustainable growth.

The firms that figure this out survive the transition to non-attorney sales teams, and they dominate their markets while maintaining the professional standards that make great law firms great.

---

Ready to build a high-performance sales team that works within legal industry constraints? Get access to our complete Sales Gravy University training platform with courses specifically designed for professional services firms and sales leadership development.