From Diotrephes To Jesus: Escaping Church Boss Syndrome

Send us Fan Mail

Power can look polished, prayerful, and even generous—until you notice every decision was made before the meeting. We take a hard look at church boss syndrome through the story of Diotrephes in 3 John and ask a pressing question: who really leads, the Spirit or the strongest personality? Drawing from pastoral experience, we reveal how quiet control grows: backchannel conversations, “concerned” phone calls, strategic lunches, and gifts that feel like blessings but function as leverage.

We unpack why control often springs from insecurity and how identity in Christ frees leaders from needing the spotlight. Then we contrast two paths: the boss who drives outcomes in the dark and the shepherd who empowers people in the light. Using 1 Peter 5 as our guide, we outline practical guardrails for healthy authority—transparent decision-making, shared leadership, documented processes, and financial policies that prevent any one giver from owning the ministry. We also name the subtle signals of manipulation: outcomes pre-set by a few, pressure on pastors to “fall in line,” and piety used to defend a seat at the table rather than to seek truth.

This conversation equips pastors, elders, deacons, and faithful members to protect the flock without becoming combative. You’ll learn how to address leverage with clarity, replace obligation with gratitude, and keep the mission central when personalities try to take the wheel. The bottom line is simple and non-negotiable: the church belongs to Christ. Authority is stewardship, not possession, and you cannot build the house of Jesus with the tools of control.

If this resonates, share it with your team, subscribe for more practical, biblical leadership insights, and leave a review to help other churches guard their hearts and keep Christ at the center.

Thanks for listening. Find us on YouTube, Substack, Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Instagram.