Skip to content
TrackPodcasts
newsSep 12, 202613:15

Murder In Moscow: Five Key Pieces Of Evidence Against Kohberger

About this episode

In January 2023, former NYPD inspector Paul Mauro argued that five pieces of evidence outlined in the probable cause affidavit had already created a potentially powerful circumstantial case against Bryan Kohberger. At the center was DNA recovered from the snap of a Ka-Bar-style knife sheath found beside Madison Mogen’s body, which investigators initially connected to Kohberger through a familial comparison involving his father. Mauro also pointed to surveillance footage of a white Hyundai Elantra traveling near the King Road residence before and after the murders, noting that the vehicle’s movements appeared to correspond with Kohberger’s cellphone activity. Phone records showed Kohberger’s device had connected to cell towers serving the area around the victims’ home on multiple occasions before the killings, while the phone stopped reporting to the network during the critical period surrounding the murders and reconnected afterward as it traveled south of Moscow and eventually back toward Pullman. Taken together, Mauro argued that the DNA, car footage and cellphone evidence reinforced one another and would have been difficult for the defense to explain away independently.

Mauro also highlighted surviving roommate Dylan Mortensen’s description of the masked man she saw leaving the house, saying her account of a tall, athletically built man with bushy eyebrows was broadly consistent with Kohberger’s appearance. He noted that investigators had also discovered a latent shoeprint along the route Mortensen said the intruder had taken, creating another piece of evidence prosecutors could potentially attempt to connect to Kohberger. Finally, Mauro pointed to Kohberger’s earlier criminology research, particularly a Reddit survey in which he had asked people who committed crimes about how they selected victims, prepared for offenses, approached targets and avoided detection. Mauro cautioned that Kohberger was still presumed innocent and that much remained unknown at that early stage, but he believed prosecutors already possessed several different categories of evidence that, when viewed together, could form a compelling narrative against him.












to contact me:


[email protected]

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-moscow-murders-and-more--5852883/support.

Get every episode summarized

Each time The Moscow Murders and More publishes, we email you a written briefing from the transcript — the topics, who appeared, and any specific claims, with the ad reads skipped.

Email me new episodes

Free for 3 shows. No card needed.

Hosts & guests

Transcript ready

223 searchable segments. Every word is indexed and playable.

Murder In Moscow: Five Key Pieces Of Evidence Against Kohberger

The Moscow Murders and More

0:00
13:15

Full transcript

The Moscow Murders and MoreMurder In Moscow: Five Key Pieces Of Evidence Against Kohberger. Machine-transcribed; use the interactive transcript above to jump the player to any line.

This is Dave Roberts. If you're heading into summer without a medical emergency kit, you're taking a risk most people don't think about until it's too late. Summer colds linger and can turn into sinus infections at last for weeks. Getting sick right before vacation can derail everything and we are traveling, finding a doctor and pharmacy is stressful. That's why I ordered medical emergency kit. It's like having an emergency care and a pharmacy right at home. It includes essential prescriptions like a moxasillin and generic z-pack to treat a wide range of common and serious illnesses. So if you wake up sick at home or on the road, you already have what you need. No waiting for your doctor, no hours at urgent care, no pharmacy lines, no co-pays, just match your symptoms to the right prescription in your guidebook or call their telemedicine doctor standing by. Start on your med sooner and feel better faster. Every home needs at least one medical emergency kit. 40 years online in minutes and it's shipped to your door and say $45 with promo code blue at urgentcairedkit.com slash blue. That's promo code blue at urgentcairedkit.com slash blue. This is Ashley Akinetti

from the almost famous podcast. You ever notice you and your spouse keep saying we need to get away but you never actually plan anything. That was us until we did something fun and spontaneous. We went to resort pass.com. There are hundreds of hotel resorts, pools and spots and private beaches that you can enjoy. You can spend the day at a luxury resort, pool spa massage without booking an overnight stay. And listen, I may have only been like 15 minutes from home but it felt like it was a whole different world. And I'm thinking this is exactly what I needed. So just go to resort pass.com, choose your resort, choose your day, luxury resort day passes start at just $1,000. Once you post your day vacation, people are going to ask where you are. Good resort pass.com slash almost famous and use the promo code almost famous to get $20 off when you spend $100. That's code almost famous at resort pass.com slash almost famous. Shop vans and Albertsons for fresh savings every time you shop. This week at

vans and Albertsons get fresh, boneless, skinless chicken breast for $199 per pound limit 10 pounds and locally grown grape re cotton candy grapes are $299 per pound with digital coupon. Plus 24 packs of Canada dry or 7 up 12 ounce cans are $499 limit one with digital coupon. Enjoy fresh and delicious savings for every meal. Hurry in. These deals won't last. Visit vans or Albertsons.com for more deals and ways to save. Everyone and welcome back to the program. Today we have an article that's discussing the five key pieces of evidence against Brian coberger. Now how ever since he's been arrested, we have been getting a little bit here, a little bit there about who he was, who his friends were, what he was up to, and some of his behavior in the aftermath of these murders. Well, what is the evidence that has led the investigators to believe that Brian coberger is the man responsible for these murders? Well, let's get to this episode from Fox News and let's see what

Paul Moro has for us. Headline Idaho murders, five key pieces of evidence against Brian coberger. This article was authored by Paul Moro. He is still only the accused and must be considered innocent until proven guilty. But the case against Brian coberger for the Idaho homicides appears strong. There remains much we don't know. And there is much more investigation and evidence to come. But with the recent release of the arrest warrant, affidavit, here's how the prosecution's evidence is stacking up the knife sheath DNA. Currently, this is the only evidence that is direct and not circumstantial. And that is true. Everything we have seen so far is circumstantial. And if we didn't have all of the evidence, the circumstantial evidence that we do have, I would be less in client to believe that coberger might be the guy here. But everything that we have,

the the circumstantial evidence that all leads to something bigger. And all of that circumstantial evidence, that is all built upon. And before you know it, you have an ironclad case, at least that's the hope of the prosecution. In the absence of the knife itself, having a sheath that matches to the same knife that caused the wounds, a fact which will need to be demonstrated, found literally besides the body of one of the victims is going to be tough to refute. And I am 100% on board with that. How are you going to explain this knife sheath in the bed with Kayley and Madison and with your DNA on it? That's going to be a tough sell in the best of times. That would be a tough sell. If you had OJ Simpson's dream team defending you. So I don't know how he's going to get around that one or how his defense team plans on challenging the veracity of that evidence. Yes, as some have proposed, coberger could

contend that someone stole or found his knife aside from being far fetched. This is unlikely to persuade because this hypothetical person's handling of the K bar through gripping sweating and perhaps even shedding his own blood before and during the attacks would have likely have obfuscated any DNA of coburgers. It is significant that the avid david pointedly states that only a single source of male DNA suspect profile was found on the sheath. So they have their work cut out for them, meaning the defense attorneys. I don't know how they're going to explain this. There was no one else's DNA on it. And even if you say, Oh, it was stolen. Well, how do you prove that? How do you prove that your knife was stolen and used in these murders? Now, if it was just the knife in the sheath, I could see you trying to make a logical defense around that. But with everything else that basically puts this dude at the scene of the crime, forget it. And we haven't even talked about yet the fact that he could

have been caught on a router at the king of the king road home or one of the neighbors homes. What if his wife, I connected to it? There's going to be a trace of that. There's going to be a bit of evidence of that. So if that's the case, that's just going to be stronger evidence for the prosecution moving forward. And if the DNA on the knife was extracted from a splatter of coburgers on blood, then even that week defense goes out the window. At this point, the DNA is the linchpin. It is no accident that the problem will cause affidavit, which is written chronologically, concludes with the DNA match to coburgers father. It was at that point that the investigators knew it was time to take the case down. So once they had that match and they were relatively sure of the person they were looking for, well, they moved in. The car videos, no license plate was obtained from the videos. Nonetheless, coburgers car not only matches the car

make and model film near the scene, but it also coincides with the movement of his mobile phone before and after the murders. For instance, there is this sequence that occurs as the car is tracked, leaving the scene and after the coburger phone has apparently been turned off. 448 AM phone goes live again on state highway 95 south of Moscow for 50 to 526 AM phone travel south on route 95 to Genesee, Idaho, then West, then North, back towards Pullman, 525 AM car on video at Washington State University 1300 Johnson Road Pullman in the vicinity of the Suspects home, 527 AM car on video at WSU along stadium way, vicinity of Suspects home, 530 AM phone pings at the coburger home. Could coburger contend that it wasn't his car? Certainly, but why then would it exactly match the movements of his cell phone?

And this is what I've said, all of this other little stuff that might not seem important or might seem mundane on its own. It all adds up to the bigger picture here and that bigger picture is pointing directly at coburger. And now that the task force has the car, it may well yield further forensic evidence, no matter how hard he tried to clean it. Oh, that's a fact. If there's forensic evidence to be found in that car, no matter how much he cleaned it, they're going to find it. They have all kinds of ways of finding old blood and even just a trace amount. Digital phone forensics. Like the car, the pings coburger's phone sent to nearby cell phone towers are more circumstantial than direct, but taken with the movement of his car, this will be tough to refute. Further, what possible reason could coburger give for his phone being in close proximity to the victim's house 12 times in the months leading up to the murders 11 of those late at night. So again, the totality of

what we see here is very damning for Brian coburger. How are you going to explain this? Look, I'm not a lawyer, right? So I certainly don't have the training, but in my opinion, dude, better call Saul. This is Matt Rogers from Los Cultures, that's with Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. This is Bowen Yang from Los Cultures, that's Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang. You know, when people try a new food and suddenly it's like, wait, that's the reaction. A lot of people are having when they first try QB mayo. It's the one with the red cap and the little baby on the bottle. You've probably seen it in the grocery store before. And if you've ever just walked past it, some people would say that's a huge mistake because this mayo is different. Most mayonnaise uses whole eggs. QB only uses egg yolks, which gives it this rich umami flavor. It's smoother, deeper and almost buttery. Once people try it, they start putting it on everything. Egg sandwiches, fries, burgers, some fans even swear by dipping pizza crust in it. And once you notice it, you start seeing it everywhere. Chefs use it, restaurants use it, people who really care about flavor use it. Never try

it, grab the bottle with the red cap next time you're at the store. Put it on just about anything, then you'll understand. QB, the original Japanese mayonnaise. This is Ashley Akineti from the almost famous podcast. You ever notice you and your spouse keep saying, we need to get away, but you never actually plan anything. That was us until we did something fun and spontaneous. We went to resort pass.com. There are hundreds of hotel resorts, pools and spots and private beaches that you can enjoy. You can spend the day at a luxury resort, pool, spa, massage without booking an overnight stay. And listen, I may have only been like 15 minutes from home, but it felt like it was a whole different world. And I'm thinking, this is exactly what I needed. So just go to resort pass.com, choose your resort, choose your day, luxury resort day passes start at just $25. Once you post your day, Kation, people are going to ask where you are. Go to resort pass.com slash almost famous and use the promo code almost famous to get $20 off when you spend $100. That's code almost famous at resort

pass.com slash almost famous. It's fall in America. Make it count at the Ram Drive into Fall sales event. Make it powerful with our strongest Ram 1500 ever. Make it move with the Ram Heavy Duty with an available Cummins diesel and make it go the distance with a 10 year or 100,000 mile powertrain limited warranty. Hurry and now for great deals during the Ram Drive into Fall sales event. Excludes fully electric vehicles applied to 2026 model year vehicles non transferable visit MoPAR.com for complete details on a copy of the powertrain limited warranty. Cummins is a registered trademark of Cummins Inc. Ram and Hemi are registered trademarks of FCA US LLC. Could he contend someone else had his phone? That would require him to identify this person unlikely. Could he contend that he lost his phone or that it was stolen? Sure. But why didn't he report that and cancel it? And if so, how to explain that the phone's activity continued to fit the pattern of his own use, calling family, for instance. So you see all of these little reasons that co burger could use for this not being him and him not being involved. None of them

are sound and none of them are going to convince a jury. Aside from the fact that he would have to explain why in the middle of the night, he was regularly in an area 10 miles from his home. There is this according to a recent interview of Steve Gonsolvus, the father of victim Kayleigh Gonsolvus. Co burger at times was so close to the victim's house his phone was picked up by their Wi-Fi. It's a wrap folks. If that's the case, creepy ass co burger is as good as cooked. The high merit copic cat. The eyewitness much has been made of Dylan Mortensen's delay in calling the police. What has been somewhat overlooked, however, is that her description of his height, physique and bushy eyebrows were all confirmatory as co burger became a suspect. Now I think that of all of their evidence, her looking at co burger here in a mask is probably the weakest evidence they have because how are you going to tell who's who underneath that mask? Sure, you could fit

the description, the same build, the bushy eyebrows, but you can't confirm 100% anyway that that was Brian co burger. If you doubt that, consider this on November 29th, roughly two weeks after the murders, two separate Washington State University campus police officers discovered co burger's car as a match to the Hyundai Alontera, the task force was seeking. They or the task force member would next have looked at the license photo of the car's owner. Now ask yourself, would co burger be in custody if Dylan had described him as five three and heavily overweight, and even if so, would the case be anywhere near as strong? That's a good point, honestly, definitely a good point. And maybe I should reevaluate about this being the weakest part of the evidence. It would just seem to me that in front of a jury, if you can't actually point to somebody in the courtroom and say, definitively, that's the person that it's not going to have as much weight.

But I guess that may be with all of the other factors, it could come into play here. Dylan's description of the suspects path when leaving the house also matches a latent footprint discovered at the scene, important evidence if it's matched to co burger. I mean, a lot of people wear a vans though, like a whole last college campus, I'm guessing a lot of those kids are wearing vans. Just about every pair of shoes I own are vans. You know, I like vans. I've been wearing them since I've been a kid and I just enjoy the way they feel on my feet. They're comfortable. And I like the shoes, but they're very popular. So I don't know how they're going to match that directly to co burger, considering my guess. And this is just a guess here that some of these kids advance themselves. So it might be a little difficult to tie that to co burger unless, of course, when they searched as apartment or rated wherever he was at, he had the shoes on him. Co burgers internet postings without a clear motive, which may never be learned, the prosecution can

introduce co burgers, previous Reddit postings in which he attempted to query criminals on what it felt like to commit crimes, what steps they took to avoid capture, how they prepared, and so on. Including the questions, why did you choose that victim or target over others? And how did you approach your victim or target? Now he's going to say that this was just a project he was working on in school. And under normal circumstances, people who drugged their shoulders and say, yeah, criminologists seems to fit the bill. But again, when you look at the totality of everything we know, all this shit looks more sinister. For their ending summations to a jury, prosecutors, labor to construct a compelling narrative, a story that explains what the accused did and why he did it. Adding co burgers intense interest in criminality and the creepy questions he had previously asked in his Reddit survey suggests a possible motive in the possible absence of one come trial

time. And again, look, you don't need motive to get the conviction. It helps. It certainly does, but you do not need motive. All you need to do is prove that the crime was committed. As noted, there is much more investigation and likely more evidence to come. For instance, the steps co burger took post murder like wearing surgical gloves and hiding his garbage. There will also be a great deal of criminal procedure. And there is also the defense's case, glimpses of what may be gained during the discovery process. But at this writing, the task force appears to have done its job. Now it's over to the prosecution. So that's definitely where it's at now, right? The investigators, their job is to find the suspect, compile all the evidence and then pass that to the prosecutors. Now it's in their court. It's up to Bill Thompson and the other prosecutors on the team to slam this bad boy home and get a conviction. All right, folks, that's going to do it for this

one. If you'd like to contact me, you can do that at Bobby Kupucci at proton mail.com. That's B-O-B-B-Y-C-A-P-U-C-C-I at proton mail.com. You can also find me on Twitter at B-O-B-Y-U-S-C-C-I. The link that I discussed can be found in the description box. This is Ashley Akinati from the almost famous podcast. You ever notice you and your spouse keep saying we need to get away, but you never actually plan anything. That was us until we did something fun and spontaneous. We went to resortpass.com. There are hundreds of hotel resorts, pools and spots and private beaches that you can enjoy. You can spend the day at a luxury resort, pool, spa, massage, without booking an overnight stay. And listen, I may have only been like 15 minutes from home, but it felt like it was a whole different world. And I'm thinking this is exactly what I needed.

It's fall in Jeep country, and during the driving to fall sales event, get a great deal on four by fours that refuse to be contained, like Jeep Wrangler, confidence built into every drive with the most awarded SUV ever, Jeep Grand Cherokee, and freedom that can't be denied, with the open air freedom and Jeep gladiator. After 85 years, it's no surprise that Jeep became America's SUV brand. Get a great deal during the Jeep driving to fall sales event. Jeep is one more awards over its lifetime than any other SUV brand, even the Jeep Gorilla Registered trademarks of FCA US LLC. It's fall in America. Make it count. At the Ram Drive Into Fall sales event, make it powerful with our strongest Ram 1500 ever. Make it move with the Ram Heavy Duty with an available Cummins diesel, and make it go the distance with a 10 year or 100,000 mile powertrain limited warranty. Hurry and now for great deals during the Ram Drive Into Fall sales event. Excludes fully electric vehicles applied to 2026 model year vehicles non-transferable visit at www.mopart.com for complete details on a copy of the powertrain limited warranty. Cummins is a registered trademark of Cummins Inc. Ram and Hemi are registered trademarks of FCA US LLC.

More episodes

More from The Moscow Murders and More

View all episodes →