Night Watch: “My Nightmare Stalker”: Inside The 12-Year Hunt For a Predator

Tonight's case and ones like it make me absolutely furious with our justice system and the lack

of protection for victims of stalking.

A Hollywood actress and her young daughter were subjected to relentlessly stalking for

over a decade.

As someone going by the name Freddie Kruger sent them letters containing extremely graphic

and violent threats.

Now both women are speaking out about the realities of stalking and the all-consuming impact it has

on victims' lives.

Let's get into it.

Emmy Award-winning actor Eva LaRue says she was at the pinnacle of her career, starring

in the hit CBS show CSI Miami, when her world came crashing down.

LaRue and her daughter Kaya endured 12 years of terror at the hands of a relentless stalker.

Hi, welcome to Crime House Daily, I'm your host Katie Ring.

Here we follow the cases making headlines now where justice is still unfolding.

Follow us wherever you're listening and if you want, add free episodes, subscribe to

Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts.

This episode discusses active criminal cases and breaking news.

The information we share is based on what's publicly available at the time of recording

and may change as new evidence comes light.

We aim to inform not to decide guilt or innocence.

So everyone mentioned is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

On this show, we spend a lot of time focused on details because details can change how

you understand a case and in travel, details change how you understand a place.

For travel that gets the details right, visit gocolet.com slash podcast and use offer

code Travel26 to get $200 off select Colette Explorations tours.

Colette's small group Explorations tours are designed with that same focus on details.

You're led by experts and locals who know the destination inside and out and groups stay

small with an average of just 19 travelers so the experience feels more personal.

You might take part in a centuries old tea ceremony in Japan guided by the meaning and

tradition behind every step or explore Southern Africa on expert led safaris that spend multiple

days on game drives giving you time to truly understand the landscape and wildlife.

With Colette, you get immersive travel bill on thoughtful planning, local expertise and

more than a century of experience behind it.

For travel that gets the details right, visit gocolet.com slash podcast and use offer

code Travel26 to get $200 off select Colette Explorations tours.

The all new 2026 Toyota RAV4 is here and it builds on everything drivers know and love

about Toyota.

With a redesigned look and modern tech that makes life behind the wheel easier than ever,

the 26 RAV4 comes standard as a hybrid, providing smooth, efficient performance for both

city streets and longer journeys while the available all-wheel drive keeps you in command

when conditions are unpredictable.

The new RAV4 is designed around the way people actually use their SUV from daily errands

to weekend adventures.

While the GR Sport model coming soon, both Sinette combined 320 horsepower in a plug-in

hybrid drivetrain with a GR tuned suspension for an even more responsive, exciting drive.

No matter which RAV4 you choose, you'll enjoy the reliability Toyota is known for, coupled

with the inspiring performance that's unique to Toyota.

Shop more and find details at Toyota.com.

The all new RAV4 from Toyota, let's go places.

Tonight we're covering a case about a Hollywood dream that turned into a nightmare.

In 2005, Eva Leroux was at the height of her career.

She had just landed a role on the hit show CSI Miami after a successful soap opera run

on the show All My Children.

But with this new role that skyrocketed Eva into the spotlight, she started getting

some unwanted attention in the form of threatening letters from a man calling himself Freddie

Krueger.

In her show, Eva was helping solve cases with her character's expertise in DNA analysis.

But in real life, it wasn't so easy.

Despite having DNA evidence and fingerprints from the letters from her stalker, nothing

was showing up.

And for years, this stalker became an invisible, faceless man, and possible to prepare for.

He could be anywhere at any time, and the fear of the unknown left Eva and her daughter

constantly fearing for their lives.

They were forced to move three times over the course of 12 years to try and escape the

torment.

Until finally in 2019, the stalker was caught.

Since then, Eva and her daughter have used their platform to spread awareness of the dangers

of the effects of stalking-related crimes.

And on November 13th, 2025, they shared their story with the world in an original documentary

that's streaming on Paramount Plus.

So where did it all begin?

Let's get into it.

Eva LaRue was born in Long Beach, California on December 27th, 1966, as the oldest of four

children.

They grew up in a town called Norco, which Eva described as a cowboy horse town, an hour

and a half away from LA.

When she was young, her parents started having constant, huge fights, and her mom ended

up fleeing with the kids.

Eva said that she grew up in a stressful environment and her family was on welfare, but that

her mom was always very loving and supportive.

Because of her situation growing up, Eva knew from a very early age that becoming a star

would be her ticket out of poverty.

She started acting in commercials at six years old and participated in Teenage Beauty

Pagents, including winning Miss California Empire 1984 when she was 17.

She graduated from Norco High School the following year and began a career in modeling, including

for the iconic lingerie brand, Fredericks of Hollywood.

Eventually, though, Eva wanted to be known for more than just her looks, so she started

her acting career.

She worked on shows like Candid Camera, but it wasn't until she began auditioning for

soap operas that her career really took off.

In 1993, when Eva was 26, she was cast in the role of Dr. Maria Santos Gray on All My

Children, one of the most iconic soaps of all time.

Eva's role on the show launched her into stardom, and Dr. Maria Santos Gray became one

of the show's most popular characters.

Eva was even nominated for a daytime Emmy for Best Supporting Actress in 1997.

The year after joining the show, Eva's on-screen romance moved into her real life when she

fell in love with her co-star, John Callahan, the actor who played her character's husband.

The chemistry between the two was undeniable, but at the time, Eva was married to the

actor, John O'Hurley, who was best known for his role as Jay Peter Minne on Seinfeld.

But her feelings for John Callahan wouldn't go away, and soon she and O'Hurley split up.

Two years after their divorce was finalized, she and Callahan tied the knot, and this new

chapter came with some other big changes in Eva's life as well.

Around the same time, she decided to leave All My Children and transition into other roles.

She booked some starring roles in sitcoms and TV movies, but she was also about to step

into another big role.

In December, 2001, 35-year-old Eva and her husband, John, welcomed their daughter, Kaya.

And after taking a few months off from acting to enjoy new motherhood, Eva and John brought

their relationship back to the small screen.

Eva returned to All My Children where she and Callahan's characters resumed their on-screen

romance.

But in real life, their romance was falling apart at the seams, and in 2005, they ended up

getting a divorce.

However, after a short period of awkwardness right after the divorce, they remained good

friends and continued to become great co-parents to their daughter, Kaya.

Meanwhile, Eva shifted her career focus once more.

She left All My Children again, but this time she landed a life-changing role as the DNA

investigator, Natalia Boavista, on the hit show CSI Miami.

Eva's starring role gave her legions of new fans and a lot of attention.

But not all of this was wanted.

But some of it turned dangerous.

In 2007, partway through Eva's second season on the show, Eva received a handwritten letter

sent to her through her manager and publicist.

The letter described gruesome things that the writer wanted to do to Eva in graphic

detail.

He wrote things like,

�My master, Satan, and I will use your beautiful body for our twisted ways.�

The letter was signed, Freddie Krueger, after the villain of the horror films Nightmare

on Elm Street.

Eva was extremely disturbed by the letter and went to talk to Mike Scott, who had been

the head of homicide at the L.A. County Sheriff's Office, and had become the tech advisor

for CSI Miami.

In his time as a police officer, he had seen a lot of stalking cases, and he knew the

unfortunate reality how basically nothing is done in our legal system to protect victims

of stalking.

He told her to call the police to notify them of the situation, but that they probably

wouldn't do anything.

She called and Mike was correct.

They noted the incident and said, �Unless you are raped, assaulted, beat up, or your

house was broken into, there's nothing we can do.�

But then over the next week, Eva received three more letters like this, all postmarked

from different cities in Ohio, and all containing graphic and violent threats.

By this point, Eva made the terrorizing realization that not only was someone stalking her,

he was coherent, the violence was escalating, and they believed the stalker was capable

of carrying out these threats.

Eva kept receiving a letter after letter, lying out the graphic details of what he was

going to do to her and her young daughter.

The contents were so graphic, Mike started to get worried how this was escalating, and

since the letters were coming from Ohio, this could become an interstate investigation,

so he reached out to his contact in the FBI.

Luckily, due to the violent nature of these letters, the FBI took this extremely seriously.

They had Eva's publicist who had been the person receiving the letters, handled the

letters with latex gloves, put them in a plastic bag, and sent them to the FBI lab

for forensic testing.

They were able to get both his DNA and fingerprints, but there were no hits on AFIS, which is the

national database for fingerprints, or CODIS, the national database for DNA.

The only time I laughed in the documentary was when Mike said that,

Yeah, CSI had a 100% solverate, and it's true, every episode ended with them catching

the killer.

But now Eva faced a strange contradiction.

Every day she'd show up to work on CSI Miami and pretend to solve crimes, but the real

life crime she was facing wasn't so easy to crack.

She felt completely powerless when it came to her own situation, but all she could do

was try to keep living her life.

She felt some safety in the fact that Kaya stayed with her dad in Palm Desert on the weekends,

but the fear was still overwhelming.

And especially without a face, anyone could be her stalker.

It could be a fan at an event, or even someone at the grocery store or in the parking lot.

She had to be hyper aware of her surroundings at all times.

When she would get home, she would get out of her car and search any hiding spaces in

the garage, and then in the house.

The CSI Miami set was one place she felt safe, but once she left that lot, the fear of

someone following her home or someone attacking her and her daughter loomed over her.

Luckily, back when she was buying her house, her friend, whose name you may recognize, Sarah

Michelle Geller, advised her to buy it under an LLC so that if she ever got a stalker

that address wouldn't be linked to her.

And although this gave them some semblance of safety, the stalker consumed her and her

daughter's lives.

In the documentary, Eva said that terror seems like such a small word when you're having

a full body breakdown.

This affected every part of her life, but she had to put it in a box every day when she

showed up for work.

She even started losing her hair.

Eva was devastated when her daughter started having nightmares.

She could feel how her stress was seeping through to her daughter, and it left her feeling

completely helpless.

Testing season is right around the corner, and this is when confidence really matters.

When kids take time to review key concepts and strengthen their skills before assessments,

it can make all the difference.

IXL helps reinforce what they're learning right now, so they walk into every test feeling

prepared, capable and confident.

IXL is an award-winning online learning platform that helps kids truly understand

what they're learning, whether they're building math confidence, strengthening reading

and writing skills, or reviewing science concepts.

Designed for students from pre-K through 12th grade, IXL delivers personalized interactive

practice that adapts to your child's level and pace.

It's an easy, effective way to support learning as the school year heads into its final

stretch.

Studies show kids who use IXL score higher on tests, proven in all 50 states.

IXL is used in 96 of the top 100 school districts in the US.

Make an impact on your child's learning, get IXL now, and listeners can get an exclusive

20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at IXLLearning.com slash audio.

Visit IXLLearning.com slash audio to get the most effective learning program out there

at the best price.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance.

What if comparing car insurance rates was as easy as putting on your favorite podcast?

With Progressive, it is.

Just visit the Progressive website to quote with all the coverages you want.

You'll see Progressive's direct rate, then their tool will provide options from other

companies so you can compare.

All you need to do is choose the rate and coverage you like.

Quote today at Progressive.com to join the over 28 million drivers who trust Progressive.

For the casualty insurance company and affiliates, comparison rates not available in all states

or situations, price is very based on how you buy.

In 2007, Eva LaRue's success on the hit show CSI Miami was overshadowed by horrifying

letters she was receiving from a stalker who identified themselves as Freddie Krueger.

It was consuming her and her daughters every waking moment and even started haunting

them in their dreams.

But when one of Eva's friends invited her in Kaya to come live with them in Italy for

a few months, while they were on a hiatus from filming CSI Miami, she jumped at the opportunity.

She thought her stalker wouldn't be able to find her in Italy and it was a time she could

finally relax and unwind.

However, that sense of protection and ease slipped away a day and a half after landing

in Italy.

Eva woke up in the middle of the night to the sound of her bedroom door opening.

The hallway light was on and Eva noticed someone standing in their doorway.

She thought it was her friend so she went back to sleep.

But in the morning, she learned that the house had been broken into.

Thankfully though, the burglar wasn't her stalker.

And in a strange way, this made Eva feel empowered.

She felt like this was her sign from God that she had been waiting for.

She believed this was God's way of saying that he was going to keep her safe.

So when CSI resumed filming, Eva and Kaya returned to the United States.

But Eva was determined not to let anything happen to her family.

And she did everything she could to prevent the stalker from finding them.

Unfortunately, the FBI still hadn't been able to identify Eva's stalker.

So she installed security cameras, gates, and listened intently to every safety tip

might give her.

She felt empowered, and like she had created a little fortress that gave them some protection.

Until something transpired, that Eva refers to as gate gate.

Eva had put up two gates in front of her house to add an extra layer of protection.

They were only six feet tall, but the town ordinance was that fences couldn't be above

five feet eight inches or so.

Despite explaining her entire situation and the seriousness of the stalker to her neighbors,

she had to go to a town hall meeting to fight to keep her two gates.

The town meeting was televised, and one of the people on the board read her address out loud.

Even after her explaining the entire situation, Hanuk immediately said in.

Paparazzi showed up at her house the very next day.

And they knew that if the paparazzi could find her, so could her stalker.

So her brother who owned a moving company was able to move her out in two days.

Luckily at this time, she had just gotten engaged to Joe Capucho, and her entire were able

to move into his home that was in a gated community, in which gave them an added sense

of security.

She thought that once she had gotten engaged, the letters would calm down, and the stalker

would realize that she was now taken.

But the stalker escalated even more.

He sent letters to Joe's work.

Eva and Kaiya said that their time with Joe was the time they felt the safest, but three

years later, the couple ended up getting a divorce.

And although there were other contributing factors that led to the breakup, the stalking

played a large role in their relationship ending.

After the divorce, Eva and Kaiya stayed in the gated community.

And by this point, all the letters had been forwarded to Eva through her publicist.

But in June of 2016, Eva walked out to get the mail and was surprised by a handwritten

letter.

But the surprise quickly turned to dread when she immediately recognized the handwriting.

After almost ten years, her biggest fear came true.

He had found their home address.

Not only that, the letter was addressed directly to her daughter, Kaiya.

Before this point, she had told Kaiya about the stalker, but I'd never mentioned how

she was also a big fixation in his letters.

She didn't tell her the details, but she needed to make sure Kaiya was aware of the seriousness

of this risk.

Kaiya was in high school at the time, and she started to feel like she was in a cage.

Every unknown face that showed up at her school could be the stalker.

She started having panic attacks in her classes, and constantly feared she would come home

to her mom tied up, mutilated, or dead.

Eva described those words as absolute psychological terrorism.

She said her worst fear was that the threats would become a reality, especially because they

were receiving so many letters.

By this point, they had gotten almost 40.

And in October of 2019, another one of her worst fears came true.

Their stalker decided to escalate things even further.

At this point, Kaiya was 17 in a senior in high school, and one day she got called to

the principal's office.

They notified her that her father had called, and he said he was going to pick her up and

that she should wait outside for him.

But Kaiya was confused, because she and her dad hadn't made any plans for him to pick

her up.

So instead of going outside, Kaiya called her mom to ask if she knew anything about it.

But Eva said no.

Then Eva called her ex-husband John to try and figure it out, and that's when John

told her he wasn't even in Los Angeles.

Eva knew right away what was going on.

Freddie had come to make good on his promises.

Plus rated PG, and right now you can get Disney Plus in Hulu for just $4.99 a month for

three months with a special limit to time offer ends March 24th.

After three months playing out over news at $12.99 a month, terms apply.

Hi listeners, it's Vanessa Richardson.

I wanted to take a brief moment to tell you about another show from Crime House that I

know you'll love.

America's most infamous crimes hosted by Katie Ring.

Each week Katie takes on a notorious crime, whether unfolding now or etched into American

history, revealing not just what happened, but how it forever changed our society.

Serial killers who terrorized cities, unsolved mysteries that keep detectives up at night,

and investigations that changed the way we think about justice.

Each case unfolds across multiple episodes, released every Tuesday through Thursday,

from the first sign that something was wrong to the moment the truth came out, or didn't.

These are the stories behind the headlines.

Coming to and follow America's most infamous crimes, Tuesday through Thursday, on Apple

podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts.

After Eva LaRue's stalker called her daughter Kaya School in October of 2019, Eva hopped

in her car immediately and rushed to pick up her daughter.

Thankfully nothing happened that day, but every possibility was running through their minds.

As he outside the school waiting for them, was he going to follow them home?

Was he finally going to make good on his promises?

They didn't know where to turn, especially because they'd already moved twice to try

and avoid any more mail.

And if their stalker was able to find her school, he obviously knew a lot more about them

than they thought.

Two new FBI agents had been assigned to her case though, and after this call they knew

they had to act fast.

They gave the school a wiretap machine to trace the calls and case he called back.

And he did nearly 20 times.

The principal's office called Kaya back in and apologized after hearing how sick and

twisted those voicemails were.

Their stalker who had been invisible for so long finally had a voice and it was terrifying.

Not only that, but he was escalating to calling which was not a good sign.

And the FBI was on it.

As they were working in the background, Kaya had to be escorted to and from the school

parking lot every day.

The high school senior feared for her life every day.

But thankfully the new agents that were assigned to the case, Steve Kramer and Steve Bush,

which I called Steve and Steve, were two of the agents who solved the infamous Golden

State Killer case.

The man who raped and murdered dozens of people during the 1970s and 80s.

It had been a cold case for 42 years, but they used genetic genealogy to finally catch

him.

Although investigators in California had the suspects of DNA, it wasn't showing up in any

of their databases.

However, with genetic genealogy, they had access to sites like 23 and me and ancestry.com.

And we're able to identify many people who shared one relative in common, a man named

Joseph James DeAngelo, who was a retired police officer from Northern California.

This discovery gave authorities everything they needed to arrest and convict DeAngelo.

About a year later, the FBI began to employ the same techniques in going after Eva and

Kaya's stalker.

When the stalker first started sending letters back in 2007, Eva's CSI Miami character

was able to use DNA to solve cold cases.

But the difference between the show and reality is that in the show the suspects DNA would

always be in the national DNA database, Kodis.

In real life, however, a person's DNA is only in Kodis if they've committed a felony,

so a lot of suspects don't ever show up.

But now with genetic genealogy, they had access to other DNA resources that could help identify

people related to the suspect and then allow them to track the suspect down.

They finally had the technology on their side.

Before Steve and Steve, the FBI was just hoping the stalker would get arrested and they

would finally get a hit, but it never happened.

But the man figured out that maybe they could use their tactics to prevent a case instead

of just solving cold cases.

They were able to use websites like 23 and me and ancestry.com to narrow down their

list of potential suspects.

The FBI already had DNA and fingerprints from the letters that he had been sending Eva

over the years.

And they started building family trees off of that DNA from the genealogy databases.

Luckily, they found a hit and one of the families was based in Ohio, where all of the letters

had been coming from.

Twelve years after Eva got her first letter, they found a suspect.

James David Rogers, a nursing assistant living in a small town in Ohio.

All signs pointed to James as a stalker, but they needed to be sure.

At the time, James worked at a memory care facility and two of the FBI agents pretended

to be a brother and sister who were looking for a place for their parents.

Before they moved in on him, they wanted to view his interactions with patients and his

day-to-day schedule.

They were disturbed that this man was caring for people's parents, but no one knew what

was really going on behind the scenes.

They were completely unaware of the sick letters he had been tormenting these two women

with four years.

FBI agents watched James as he went about his day.

They followed him as he left work and ate at an Arby's restaurant.

When he threw away his drink, the agents took the straw for DNA testing.

And when they got the results back, it matched the DNA sample taken from the envelopes.

One morning in November of 2019, not long after he'd left another voicemail at Kaya School,

agents descended on James at his house and arrested him.

James was a 52-year-old out-of-shape white guy who was living with his mom and sister.

When his mom and sister were interviewed, they said they both had no clue what he was doing

behind the scenes.

But as a kid, they would watch all my children together and he would watch it over and over.

The FBI believed this is when his fascination first started.

It was a huge day for Ivan Kaya, and it was also a milestone for law enforcement.

Because according to the FBI, it was the first time forensic genealogy had solved a case

at the federal level.

Cases like the Golden State Killer were handled by local investigators.

James was charged with two counts of mailing threatening communications, one count of threats

by interstate communications, and two counts of stalking.

He was looking at a maximum of 25 years in prison.

James pleaded guilty on all counts, and at his sentencing in September of 2022, he appealed

to the court by describing his abusive childhood and how he'd been bullied as a kid.

He also spoke directly to Eva, saying, I sincerely apologize for what I did for the last

12 years, putting you and your family through hellish behavior.

I accept full responsibility.

I hope you can put this behind you, and at some point, never think about me again.

Eva said at first, Kaya didn't want to speak, but once she heard this man who had ruined

their lives, give ridiculous excuses for his actions, and pleading for forgiveness and

asking them if they could just put it behind them, she popped up and spoke her truth.

Her mom was so proud, and it was a moment where she felt Kaya really took her power back.

Eva didn't think she could put it behind her either, and her victim impact statement

she said, I forgive you, but I cannot forget.

The fear is with me forever.

In the end, the court decided to go easy on James, and he was sentenced to 40 months

in prison, which is just over three years, with another three years of probation after

that.

Eva said that him only getting a little more than three years for 12 years of stalking

was more than disappointing, it was devastating.

They were relieved that they could stop looking over their shoulders for the next few years,

but she also told the court she was worried what James would do once he got out of prison.

After only 24 months served, James was released from prison, and his probation will end in

2027.

But rather than go back to living in fear, Eva and Kaya decided to speak out.

On November 13th, 2025, the documentary, My Nightmare Stalker, The Eva LaRue Story,

aired on Paramount Plus.

In it, both women speak candidly about what they experienced during those 12 years and

afterward.

We absolutely need reform in how stalking is handled and charged.

It makes me sick to my stomach how often nothing is done about stalking until the victim

is killed.

How can someone only be punished for 24 months after terrorizing a woman and her daughter

for 12 years?

He ruined the quality of their lives, ruined relationships, made them constantly look

over their shoulder thinking any person at any time could be the person who would come

after them and do these horrible things he wrote.

These actions cause nightmares, panic attacks, and hopelessness.

How are these devastating effects on these victims not met with the same level of repercussions?

Also, if you're watching, this is a picture of the stalker.

All these years, they said they had pictured a ten-bundy kind of character.

But this guy was an old, out-of-shape, 52-year-old loser living in his mom's basement, with

two contacts in his phone, his mom, and Kaya's school.

All this time, this man who could barely walk, terrorized them, and the whole time, they

probably could have kicked his ass.

These cases make me so mad, because there is zero justice.

And I'm hoping, with exposure to cases like this, we can finally make some progress.

I also hope that Eva and Kaya can also find the time and space to focus on themselves

and their own healing.

As always, we'll be sure to update you with any further developments on this story.

What did you think of tonight's case?

Drop your thoughts and theories in the comments.

See you next time.

If you haven't already, subscribe to our YouTube channel at Crimes House Daily, and follow

us on social media at Crimes House 24-7 for real-time updates, because a pursuit of justice

never stops.

Data isn't just information, it's influence, and a world shaped by algorithms.

The real impact comes from the people behind them, those who bring judgment to the numbers

and ethics to the decisions.

At Virginia Tech, the MS in Data Science prepares you to turn insight into action and strategy

into real-world impact.

Thanks for listening to today's episode.

Not sure what to listen to next?

Check out America's Most Infamous Crimes hosted by Katie Ring.

From serial killers to unsolved mysteries and game-changing investigations, each week Katie

takes on a notorious criminal case in American history.

Listen to and follow America's Most Infamous Crimes now, wherever you listen to podcasts.