Paid Testimonials, Gift Cards & a 3.5 Hour Drive: What Really Happens When You Fight Big Money at the Capitol

What happens when a Silicon Valley company offers homeowners $50 Amazon gift cards to submit favorable testimony to a state legislature, and doesn't disclose it? I watched it happen in real time.

In this episode, I'm telling the full story of the day I drove 3.5 hours to the Pennsylvania State Capitol to testify in support of HB 2120, a bill that would require home equity investments (HEIs), also called shared appreciation agreements or home equity sharing agreements, to be regulated as mortgage products under Pennsylvania's usury law.

What I witnessed was a masterclass in how money, lobbyists, and carefully placed friendships work behind the scenes to slow down consumer protections. And it got picked up by Spotlight PA.

We cover:

• What home equity agreements actually are — and why the math should scare you
• Why these products aren't regulated as loans in most states (yet)
• How Point, one of the largest HEI companies, offered customers $50 gift cards to submit written testimony — without disclosing the payments
• Why one company CEO couldn't tell a legislative committee how much a consumer would owe on his own product
• The Urban Institute report the industry cited — and what it actually said
• Why the National Association of Realtors was nowhere to be found (and why that's worth asking about)
• What this fight says about how consumer protection legislation actually works — and who's really in your corner

If you took out a home equity investment or shared appreciation agreement and have a balloon payment coming, you need to understand what's at stake. And if you haven't taken one out yet — listen before you do.

Mentioned in this episode:

• PA Representative Arvind Venkat
• HB 2120 (Pennsylvania House Commerce Committee)
• Spotlight PA: "A Silicon Valley firm offered gift cards as part of a campaign to defeat Pa. regulation"
• David Friend, former CFPB Counsel
• National Consumer Law Center
• Community Legal Services of Philadelphia

Got a question?

Support the show

State laws and regulations may vary.

Have a story you would like to share with other sellers or buyers?
Hit us up here.