The Mask We Wear: Leadership, Identity, and the Emotional Cost of Visibility with Matthew Krayton

Get in touch with us! We’d appreciate your feedback and comments.

“Many leaders aren’t just performing for the public—they’re performing for themselves.” - Matthew Krayton

Leadership today is less about perfection and more about presence. In this episode, Matthew Krayton, leadership advisor and co-founder of M2Aspire, shares how leaders can align strategy with values, manage emotional intensity, and drop the performance mask to lead with clarity and authenticity—especially in the spotlight.

Are you leading from who you truly are—or from a version of yourself designed to meet others' expectations?

Key Takeaway Insights & Tools (with Timestamps)

• You’ll never please everyone—stop trying.
  Strong leadership begins with letting go of the need to satisfy all audiences and instead anchoring decisions in your values.
  [08:24]
• Pause before responding.
  Emotional reactions often outweigh data in leadership decisions. Build the habit of pausing before reacting to create distance from emotional triggers.
  [13:50]
• Use emotional labeling to regulate tough conversations.
  Internally or aloud, naming emotions—like "This is frustration"—helps shift from reaction to response.
  [19:32]
• Curiosity beats defensiveness.
  In tense situations, lead with curiosity instead of argument. Phrases like “Help me understand” reduce conflict and build connection.
  [18:06]
• Don’t skip mindset work.
  Leaders often jump to tactics and execution without building the internal foundation to handle pressure. Emotional fitness and clarity are prerequisites to effective leadership.
  [34:50]

Bio

Matthew Krayton is the Co-Founder of M2Aspire, where he helps founders, executives, and teams align strategy with story - especially during times of growth, reinvention, or internal misalignment. Through a blend of coaching, advisory, and communications strategy, he supports leaders navigating the emotional and strategic toll of visibility.

Matt previously founded Publitics, a nationally recognized public affairs firm, where he advised campaigns at every level of government and worked on special projects during the 2020 presidential race, including helping to create President Joe Biden’s viral “We Just Did” hat.

He also teaches in Centenary University’s Business Department, where he serves as an adjunct professor in their pioneering social media program. Earlier in his career, Matt worked at Fairleigh Dickinson University’s PublicMind Poll and taught in the Law in the Liberal Arts program.

• Website: m2aspire.com
• LinkedIn: Matthew Krayton
• Substack: M2Aspire on Substack
• Instagram: @m2aspire

Related Past Episodes:

• [Leading Through Change and Chaos with Marianne B. Hagen]
• [Building Psychological Safety at Work with Dr. Chika Oriuwa]

If this episode made you rethink how you show up as a leader, share it with someone navigating leadership challenges right now. And don’t forget to subscribe to It’s an Inside Job for more insights that help you lead from the inside out.

Support the show

Sign up for the weekly IT'S AN INSIDE JOB NEWSLETTER

• takes 5 seconds to fill out
• receive a fresh update every Wednesday